Three-dimensional printing in orthopaedic surgery: A review of current and future applications
Article History
-
Received: ,
Accepted: ,
Abstract
Abstract
Three-dimensional (3D) printing is a form of technology in which 3D physical models are created. It has been used in a variety of surgical specialities ranging from cranio-maxillo-facial to orthopaedic surgery and is currently an area of much interest within the medical profession. Within the field of orthopaedic surgery, 3D printing has several clinical applications including surgical education, surgical planning, manufacture of patient-specific prostheses/patient specific instruments and bone tissue engineering. This article reviews the current practices of 3D printing in orthopaedic surgery in both clinical and pre-clinical settings along with discussing its potential future applications.
Keywords
This article was originally published by Reed Elsevier India Pvt. Ltd. and was migrated to Scientific Scholar after the change of Publisher.
1 Introduction
Three-dimensional (3D) printing was developed in the 1980s, for use in the industry and manufacturing fields.1–3 However, over the last 10 years much research has been undertaken to explore its applications within healthcare settings.1
Within orthopaedic surgery, 3D printing has multiple clinical applications including surgical planning, surgical education, manufacture of patient-specific prostheses and bone tissue engineering.4 This article reviews the current practices of 3D printing in orthopaedics and its future applications.
2 What is 3D printing?
The main 3D printing technique used in orthopaedic surgery is an additive process.4 This involves a physical model being created by laying down successive layers of material.5 The final object can be identical in form and function to the original design and, in the case of implants, can be identical to those produced by traditional manufacturing techniques.6 Therefore, in theory, a 3D printed femur could be identical to its original, organic counterpart.
The initial step is image acquisition, normally obtained from either CT or MRI scans. However, generally, image acquisition for 3D printing in orthopaedic surgery is obtained from CT imaging as bone has a higher contrast & exposure than soft tissue on this imaging modality.7
Following image acquisition, the images are processed for 3D printing allowing the creation of digitised computer aided file, which can then be sent to a printer.6
Current clinical applications within orthopaedic surgery.
3 Surgical education
Surgical procedures require in-depth knowledge of anatomy and the relationship between structures.
Research has been conducted to explore the use of 3D printing in anatomy education.8 Chen et al. (2017) conducted a randomised-controlled trial on the use of 3D printed models to teach medical students the anatomy of the skull and found models improved students’ knowledge of the anatomy.2 Cai et al. (2019) demonstrated 3D printed simulation of the knee joint improved medical students understanding of both anatomy and function when compared to didactic teaching methods.9 However, these benefits may only be limited to areas of complex bony anatomy, with Wu et al. (2018) demonstrating 3D printing showed advantages for undergraduate learning in the pelvis and spine but not for upper and lower limbs.10
3D printing also has a role to play at the postgraduate level. 3D printing can allow intensive training for junior surgeons, simulating common procedures, allowing them to practise patient-specific operations in advance of the true surgery.4,11 This allows for the development of surgical skills with minimal risk to patients. By practicing on physical models, it could shorten operative time, give better understanding of the fracture pattern and reduce iatrogenic complications.12,13
4 Surgical planning
Prior to the commencement of any surgical procedure, sufficient surgical planning should be undertaken. Most surgeons will employ their own individualised methods but generally this consists of taking 2D images and converting them into a 3D plan.14 However, for complex injuries, or for trainee surgeons, this can be challenging.12
Over the last 10 years, 3D printing has been successfully used within orthopaedics for surgical planning.7 Its use can be split into two main areas: surgical guides and surgical instruments.
4.1 Surgical guides
3D printing can be used to create surgical guides that help surgeons plan and perform complex procedures with greater accuracy.7 These guides can be based on 3D models of a patient's anatomy, which can help surgeons to visualize the surgical site, understand the fracture and plan the best approach.13
Several studies have investigated the impact of 3D printing in spinal surgery. Wu et al. (2011) assessed the accuracy and safety of rapid prototyping (3D printing) as a guide for pedicle screw placements in patients with severe congenital scoliosis.15 They compared the role of 3D printing for preoperative and perioperative planning to conventional fluoroscopy and reported a significant improvement in accuracy of screw insertion.15 This conclusion is reinforced by Sheha et al. (2019) who stated preoperative 3D modelling improves surgical accuracy and intraoperative speed while decreasing blood loss in spine surgery for complex deformity.16
Similar benefits have been demonstrated using 3D printing in pelvic fractures and acetabular trauma.14,17 Wu et al. (2015) utilised 3D printed models as anatomic templates for virtual preoperative planning in pelvic fractures with these being beneficial to the understanding of fracture anatomy, which shortened operative time, improved the final fixation and improved operative outcomes.13 Furthermore, in some cases these 3D models could be used to pre-contour plates to be used intraoperatively for fracture reduction and fixation.14
Therefore, we can clearly see the positive impacts that 3D printing can have in preoperative planning for complex procedures.
4.2 Surgical instruments
3D printing can be used to create specialised surgical instruments that are customised to the needs of a particular procedure.14 Surgeons may use 3D-printed instruments to assist with delicate procedures such as microsurgery or spinal surgery.14,18 Customised instruments can be designed to fit the specific needs of the surgeon and the procedure, which may improve the accuracy and effectiveness of the surgery.
The impact of patient specified instruments (PSI) has been analysed in a range of orthopaedic surgeries, namely shoulder arthroplasty, hip arthroplasty and spinal surgery.19–21 Due to improper component position leading to acetabular loosening, there has been an increase in the use of PSI in the pre-operative and intraoperative planning of total hip arthroplasties (THA).18,20 A systematic review by Constantinescu et al. (2022) assessed the efficacy of PSI in total hip arthroplasty.18 It concluded that PSI are effective in improving acetabular component positioning and postoperative outcomes, without increasing intraoperative time or blood loss, when compared to standard instrumentation.18 Further studies have also highlighted the positive impact of PSI on implant positioning accuracy and have also emphasised its role in reconstructing in complex anatomy, particularly in cases of developmental dysplasia of the hip.22 A drawback of these studies is the limited data on long-term outcomes, meaning more work is required to provide a more comprehensive overview of PSI in THA.
Another limitation is potential incorrect bony placement. This can occur as the accurate fit between a PSI and the bony surface is reliant on sufficient accurate registration features.14 This is a particular issue in patients with osteoarthritis where osteophytes can be poorly detected on imaging, leading to the PSI footprint not matching the intraoperative bony findings.23 Given many patients have some osteoarthritic changes, this has the potential to be a significant drawback to PSI use. Furthermore, PSI do not generally have intraoperative feedback on position, relying on the feeling of fit by the surgeon meaning deviation from pre-op planned positioning may not be detected intraoperatively.14,24
So, whilst 3D printed PSI appear promising for a range of uses in orthopaedics further research is required.
5 Manufacture of patient-specific prostheses
Another important use of 3D printing is the ability to manufacture patient-specific prostheses.
3D printing technology can be used to create customised implants that are tailored to the specific shape and size of a patient's bone.14 As well as being unique to the patient's anatomy, these can also be 3D printed into a lattice shape the allows osseointegration.25 Furthermore, 3D printed custom prosthesis can undergo biomechanical loading evaluation prior to implant insertion along with being printed into geometrical structures that could never be achieved with traditional techniques.14,26
One use of 3D printed prosthesis is within bone tumour reconstruction surgery. 3D printed custom implants can be created for the unique bony abnormalities caused by tumours, being particularly useful where no off the shelf prosthesis exist.27 Early studies have shown positive outcomes in a range of bony sites, including pelvic and clavicular tumours, with Safali et al. (2023) reporting both good anatomical and functional outcomes with shortened surgical time and high patient satisfaction.28
Another area of use is within complex revision hip arthroplasty, particularly for acetabular bone loss, however it is currently unclear whether these offer substantial clinical improvements. Colen et al. (2013) report positive outcomes on the use of modified custom-made triflanged acetabular reconstruction rings with good clinical and radiological outcomes.29 However, Wind et al. (2013) did not report similar improved outcomes compared to traditional methods and warned ‘surgeon and patient expectations should be realistic’.30 Furthermore, these 3D custom implants are currently both time consuming and costly.14 As such, further research is needed to ascertain the exact clinical scenarios within which 3D printed prosthesis may be beneficial.
Finally, websites have begun to offer source files of designs for 3D printable prostheses for download.31 Therefore, any hospital with access to a 3D printer can produce cheap prosthetics from available source files although these are not patient specific.
6 Bioprinting and bone tissue engineering
6.1 Bioprinting
Researchers are exploring the use of 3D printing to create living tissue, a process known as bioprinting. The basic process of 3D bioprinting is identical to the manufacture of non-biological objects. Layer upon layer of precisely positioned biological materials, biochemical and living cells are used to generate a 3D structure.32
The three leading bioprinting techniques are pressure-assisted, laser-assisted, and inkjet-based.33,34 Pressure-based printing uses a physical force from air pressure to deposit a continuous stream of tissue material.33 In a laser-assisted printing method such as laser-induced forward transfer (LIFT),34 a laser is focused on a coated intermediate layer, with a drop from the focus point then being deposited on the target surface. Finally, inkjet-based methods eject droplets through use of an actuator.35
Within orthopaedics, 3D bioprinting is being researched for its potential use in the develop of replacement bones and other tissues.36 In laboratory studies bioprinting has shown promise in being a solution to both large sized bone defects and intra-articular cartilage repair.37,38 However, the promising results in studies have been carried out in conditions where there is continuous stimulus for vascularised bone regeneration and so may not be replicable in vivo, where patients will have localised inflammation and variable oxygen delivery.35 Therefore, substantially more research is required.
6.2 Bone tissue engineering
Another promising area of research is bone tissue engineering. Tissue engineering proposes to repair bone through local transplantation of biosynthetic material to defects.39 Within bone tissue engineering 3D printing is used to create a bio-scaffolds which allows new bone tissue to be grown.4
When selecting the scaffold material, multiple factors must be considered including the mechanical properties, biocompatibility, biodegradability. The scaffold can either natural or synthetic polymeric grafts, being tailored to the patient and loaded with growth factors or osteogenic cells.40 Natural polymeric scaffolds are derived from sources such as collagen, hyaluronate and alginate.40 They generally do not elicit an inflammatory response since they are biocompatible. However, there is variability between scaffolds and their long-term viability may be inadequate. Synthetic polymeric scaffolds are advantageous because of their availability, their uniformity, and their ability to be mechanically altered for different needs. However, are less biocompatible and their degradation can be an issue.40
Much of the current research has focused on use of bone tissue engineering in critical bone defects. Various papers have investigated the use of recombinant human bone morphogenic protein-2 (rhBMP-2) in open tibial fractures when being used alongside a tibial nail, opposed to a 3D printed matrix.41–43 However, variable benefit has been shown. Govender et al. (2002) reported that implants with rhBMP-2 showed accelerated bone and tissue healing in tibial fractures.41 However, more recent similar studies have shown no improvement in healing compared to routine care.42,43
Variable results have also been shown in animal models for bone tissue engineering. Decambron et al. (2017) found no significant difference between new bone formation on a coral scaffold for metatarsal defects in sheep.44 However, promise has been shown on in treating rat femoral defects.45,46 Baker et al. (2016) concluded polymer scaffolds were able to integrate with bone after 12 weeks and maintained defect stability.45 Furthermore, Bosemark et al. (2015) showed a synthetic scaffold with bone morphogenetic proteins as growth factors with bisphosphonates improved callus formation in rat femoral defects.46
Given the promise in preclinical animal models the next steps are to move into clinical trials. However, there are multiple barriers to this. One is that any bone tissue engineering needs sufficient bony vascularity in the region for graft success.40 Furthermore, many of the material and therapies used with bone tissue engineering are not yet approved in humans so regulatory approval is required.40 Despite this, bone tissue engineering could provide an exciting future solution to many orthopaedic issues.
7 Future applications within orthopaedic surgery
The future for 3D printing in orthopaedic surgery is vast and exciting.
In osteochondral repair, Zhang et al. (2014) implanted a 3D printed matrix into rabbit trochlea. From sixteen to fifty-two weeks post-implantation, a hyaline-like cartilage was noted to have begun forming.47 With further research, this could have a significant impact on osteoarthritis and other rheumatological conditions.
Another area for development could be within management of periprosthetic joint infections. Current clinical practice includes usage of an antibiotic eluting polymethylmethacrylate (PMMA) spacer or liner. However, these have various issues including unstable elution of antibiotics along with only being able to use heat stable antibiotics.48 Kim et al. (2019) discussed how a 3D printed liner made of polylactic acid (PLA) could overcome these issues.49 They reported PLA could be act as a controlled drug delivery vehicle since antibiotics can be directly incorporated into 3D printed polymer.49 Building on this Allen et al. (2020) demonstrated that, in vitro, 3D printed reservoirs can reliably deliver controllable antibiotic release.50 However, the proposed designs from the current research have not yet been transferred to a clinical setting and so further work is needed.48
8 Conclusions
3D printing has the potential to significantly impact orthopaedic surgery.
Surgical guides, designed using 3D printing, are already being used aiding in the planning and execution of complex procedures. Furthermore, specialised patient specified surgical instruments (PSI) are now able to be 3D printed, streamlining procedures and improving outcomes.
Soon, customised implants, made to fit the specific shape and size of a patient's bone, may become widespread and lead to more precise surgery and faster recovery times.
Further in the future, bioprinting may allow the development of replacement bones and other tissues. Alongside this, bone tissue engineering has the possibility to change the management of critical bone defects if promising in vitro results can transfer to clinical practice. Finally, antibiotic eluting 3D printed polymers could transform the management of peri-prosthetic infections.
So, whilst the future looks promising for the use of 3D printing in orthopaedic surgery, it will likely be some time before these technologies are widely implemented in clinical practice.
Ethical consent
None needed.
Funding
This research did not receive any specific grant from funding agencies in the public, commercial or not for profit sectors.
Guardian/patient's consent
None needed.
CRediT authorship contribution statement
Gajendiran Thiruchandran: Conceptualization, Investigation, Writing – original draft, Supervision. Oliver Dean: Investigation, Writing – original draft, Writing – review & editing, Project administration. Duaa Alim: Investigation, Writing – original draft. Adrian Crawford: Investigation, Writing – original draft. Omar Salim: Investigation, Writing – original draft.
References
- 3D printing: clinical applications in orthopaedics and traumatology. EFORT Open Rev. 2017 Mar 13;1(5):121-127.
- [Google Scholar]
- The role of three-dimensional printed models of skull in anatomy education: a randomized controlled trail. Sci Rep. 2017 Apr 3;7(1):575.
- [Google Scholar]
- The use of three-dimensional printing technology in orthopaedic surgery. J Orthop Surg. 2017 Jan;25(1)
- [Google Scholar]
- Additive manufacturing applications in orthopaedics: a review. J Clin Orthop Trauma. 2018 Jul-Sep;9(3):202-206.
- [Google Scholar]
- A Comprehensive Study on 3D Printing Technology. 2016;vol. 6:63-69.
- [Google Scholar]
- Additive manufacturing as a DISRUPTIVE technology: IMPLICATIONS OF three-dimensional printing. Technol Innovat. 2013;15:67-79.
- [Google Scholar]
- 3D-printed patient-specific applications in orthopedics. Orthop Res Rev. 2016 Oct 14;8:57-66.
- [Google Scholar]
- Introducing 3-dimensional printing of a human anatomic Pathology specimen: potential benefits for undergraduate and postgraduate education and anatomic pathology practice. Arch Pathol Lab Med. 2015 Aug;139(8):1048-1051.
- [Google Scholar]
- The effects of a functional three-dimensional (3D) printed knee joint simulator in improving anatomical spatial knowledge. Anat Sci Educ. 2019 Nov;12(6):610-618.
- [Google Scholar]
- The addition of 3D printed models to enhance the teaching and learning of bone spatial anatomy and fractures for undergraduate students: a randomized controlled study. Ann Transl Med. 2018 Oct;6(20):403.
- [Google Scholar]
- Applications of three-dimensional printing in surgery. Surg Innov. 2017 Feb;24(1):82-88.
- [Google Scholar]
- Rapid prototyping in the assessment, classification and preoperative planning of acetabular fractures. Injury. 2007 Oct;38(10):1158-1162.
- [Google Scholar]
- Printed three-dimensional anatomic templates for virtual preoperative planning before reconstruction of old pelvic injuries: initial results. Chin Med J (Engl). 2015 Feb 20;128(4):477-482.
- [Google Scholar]
- 3D-printed patient-specific applications in orthopedics. Orthop Res Rev. 2016 Oct 14;8:57-66.
- [Google Scholar]
- Accuracy and safety assessment of pedicle screw placement using the rapid prototyping technique in severe congenital scoliosis. J Spinal Disord Tech. 2011 Oct;24(7):444-450.
- [Google Scholar]
- Application of computer-generated stereolithography and interpositioning template in acetabular fractures: a report of eight cases. J Orthop Trauma. 2002 May;16(5):347-352.
- [Google Scholar]
- The efficacy of patient specific instrumentation (PSI) in total hip arthroplasty (THA): a systematic review and meta-analysis. J Orthop. 2022 Oct 7;34:404-413.
- [Google Scholar]
- A novel patient-specific navigational template for cervical pedicle screw placement. Spine. 2009 Dec 15;34(26):E959-E966.
- [Google Scholar]
- Tailor-made surgical guide reduces incidence of outliers of cup placement. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2010 Apr;468(4):1088-1095.
- [Google Scholar]
- 3D-printed patient- specific guides for hip arthroplasty. J Am Acad Orthop Surg. 2018 Aug 15;26(16):e342-e348.
- [Google Scholar]
- Effect of patient-specific instrument on lowering threshold for junior physicians to perform total hip arthroplasty on developmental dysplasia of the hip patients. Int Orthop. 2020 Jul;44(7):1281-1286.
- [Google Scholar]
- The influence of osteophyte depiction in CT for patient-specific guided hip resurfacing procedures. Int J Comput Assist Radiol Surg. 2015 Jun;10(6):717-726.
- [Google Scholar]
- Comparison of planned and achieved implant position in total knee arthroplasty with patient-specific positioning guides. Acta Orthop. 2015 Apr;86(2):201-207.
- [Google Scholar]
- Bone growth in rapid prototyped porous titanium implants. J Biomed Mater Res. 2008 Jun 1;85(3):664-673.
- [Google Scholar]
- One-step reconstruction with a 3D- printed, biomechanically evaluated custom implant after complex pelvic tumor resection. Comput Aided Surg. 2015;20(1):14-23.
- [Google Scholar]
- Clinical study of 3D printed personalized prosthesis in the treatment of bone defect after pelvic tumor resection. J Orthop Translat. 2021 Jun 30;29:163-169.
- [Google Scholar]
- The possibilities of personalized 3D printed implants-A case series study. Medicina (Kaunas). 2023 Jan 28;59(2):249.
- [Google Scholar]
- A modified custom-made triflanged acetabular reconstruction ring (MCTARR) for revision hip arthroplasty with severe acetabular defects. Acta Orthop Belg. 2013 Feb;79(1)
- [Google Scholar]
- The NIH 3D print exchange: a public resource for bioscientific and biomedical 3D prints. 3D Print Addit Manuf. 2014 Sep 1;1(3):137-140.
- [Google Scholar]
- 3D bioprinting of the kidney—hype or hope? In AIMS Cell and Tissue Engineering. American Institute of Mathematical Sciences (AIMS). 2018;2(3):119-162.
- [Google Scholar]
- Laser-induced forward transfer: a method for printing functional inks. Crystals. 2020;10(8):651.
- [Google Scholar]
- Stem cell-laden hydrogel-based 3D bioprinting for bone and cartilage tissue engineering. Front Bioeng Biotechnol. 2022 May 17;10
- [Google Scholar]
- 3D bioprinting for cartilage and osteochondral tissue engineering. Adv Healthc Mater. 2017 Nov;6(22)
- [Google Scholar]
- Three-dimensional (3D) printed scaffold and material selection for bone repair. Acta Biomater. 2019 Jan 15;84:16-33.
- [Google Scholar]
- Induction of articular chondrogenesis by chitosan/hyaluronic-acid-based biomimetic matrices using human adipose-derived stem cells. Int J Mol Sci. 2019 Sep 11;20(18):4487.
- [Google Scholar]
- The meaning, the sense and the significance: translating the science of mesenchymal stem cells into medicine. Nat Med. 2013 Jan;19(1):35-42.
- [Google Scholar]
- Clinical applications of bone tissue engineering in orthopedic trauma. Curr Pathobiol Rep. 2018 Jun;6(2):99-108.
- [Google Scholar]
- Recombinant human bone morphogenetic protein-2 for treatment of open tibial fractures: a prospective, controlled, randomized study of four hundred and fifty patients. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2002 Dec;84(12):2123-2134.
- [Google Scholar]
- Efficacy and safety of recombinant human bone morphogenetic protein-2/calcium phosphate matrix for closed tibial diaphyseal fracture: a double- blind, randomized, controlled phase-II/III trial. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2013 Dec 4;95(23):2088-2096.
- [Google Scholar]
- Recombinant human bone morphogenetic protein-2: a randomized trial in open tibial fractures treated with reamed nail fixation. J Bone Joint Surg Am.. 2011 May 4;93(9):801-808.
- [Google Scholar]
- Low-dose BMP-2 and MSC dual delivery onto coral scaffold for critical-size bone defect regeneration in sheep. J Orthop Res. 2017 Dec;35(12):2637-2645.
- [Google Scholar]
- Self-deploying shape memory polymer scaffolds for grafting and stabilizing complex bone defects: a mouse femoral segmental defect study. Biomaterials. 2016 Jan;76
- [Google Scholar]
- The masquelet induced membrane technique with BMP and a synthetic scaffold can heal a rat femoral critical size defect. J Orthop Res. 2015 Apr;33(4):488-495.
- [Google Scholar]
- Cartilage repair and subchondral bone migration using 3D printing osteochondral composites: a one- year-period study in rabbit trochlea. BioMed Res Int. 2014;2014
- [Google Scholar]
- Application of 3D printing in hip and knee arthroplasty: a narrative review. Indian J Orthop. 2020 Oct 6;55(Suppl 1):14-26.
- [Google Scholar]
- 3D printed liner for treatment of periprosthetic joint infections. Med Hypotheses. 2017 May;102:65-68.
- [Google Scholar]
- Modulating antibiotic release from reservoirs in 3D-printed orthopedic devices to treat periprosthetic joint infection. J Orthop Res. 2020 Oct;38(10):2239-2249.
- [Google Scholar]

