Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors
Search in posts
Search in pages
Filter by Categories
Case Report
Clinical research study
Current Issue
Editorial Board
Literature Review
Narrative review
Original Article
Research Article
Review Article
Short Report
Surgical techniques
Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis
Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors
Search in posts
Search in pages
Filter by Categories
Case Report
Clinical research study
Current Issue
Editorial Board
Literature Review
Narrative review
Original Article
Research Article
Review Article
Short Report
Surgical techniques
Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis
View/Download PDF
49 (); 156-166
doi:
10.1016/j.jor.2023.12.014

Translate:

Quadriceps tendon autograft is promising with lower graft rupture rates and better functional Lysholm scores than hamstring tendon autograft in pediatric ACL reconstruction. A systematic review and meta-analysis

Author affiliations
Clinical Fellow, Paediatric Orthopaedic Division, Children's Hospital, London Health Science Centre, London, Ontario, Canada
Department of Orthopaedics, Post Graduate Institute of Medical Education and Research (PGIMER), Chandigarh, India
Cincinnati Children's Hospital Medical Center, University of Cincinnati College of Medicine, USA
Article History
Corresponding author(s)

∗Corresponding author: Karthick Rangasamy. drsrk05@gmail.com

Article tools · PDF & citations

Abstract

Abstract

Graft rupture is the most prevalent complication following pediatric anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR). The hamstring tendon (HT) autograft is frequently employed, while the quadriceps tendon (QT) autograft has garnered increased attention recently. This study aims to perform a systematic review to assess the complication rates and functional outcomes associated with these two widely used autografts in skeletally immature patients - comparing HT versus QT autografts.

Is QT autograft better than HT autograft for ACLR in skeletally immature cohorts?

Three electronic databases (PubMed/Medline, Scopus, and Ovid) were comprehensively searched to identify pertinent articles reporting the outcomes of HT and QT autografts in pediatric ACLR with a minimum 2-year follow-up. Data on the outcome parameters, such as graft rupture rates, contralateral ACL injury rates, functional outcomes, and growth disturbances rates, were extracted. Meta-analysis was performed using OpenMeta Analyst software.

Twelve studies were included for meta-analysis (pooled analysis) with 659 patients (QT: 205; HT: 454). The analysis showed that QT autografts had a significantly lesser graft rupture rate than HT autografts (3.5 % [95 % CI 0.2, 6.8] and 12.4 % [95 % CI 6.1, 18.7] respectively, p < 0.001). The graft rupture rates between QT with bone and without bone block showed no statistically significant difference (4.6 % [95 % CI 0.8, 1.0] and 3.5 % [95 % CI 2.0, 8.9] respectively, p = 0.181). The overall contralateral ACL injury rate was 10.2 %, and the subgroup analysis revealed no statistically significant difference between the QT and HT groups (p = 0.7). Regarding functional outcome scores at the final follow-up, the mean Lysholm score demonstrated a significant increase in the QT group compared to the HT group (p < 0.001). There were no significant differences between the two groups concerning growth disturbances at the final follow-up. Return to sports (RTS) varied between 6 and 13.5 months after surgery.

QT autografts demonstrate encouraging outcomes, showcasing lower graft rupture rates, better functional outcomes, and comparable contralateral ACL injury rates and growth disturbances relative to the commonly used HT autograft in skeletally immature patients undergoing ACLR.

Keywords

  • ACL
  • ACLR
  • Autograft
  • Children
  • Graft rupture
  • Hamstring
  • Pediatric
  • Quadriceps
Disclaimer:
This article was originally published by Reed Elsevier India Pvt. Ltd. and was migrated to Scientific Scholar after the change of Publisher.
1

1 Introduction

In recent years, there has been a growing recognition and surgical intervention for anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injuries in the pediatric and adolescent demographic.1 Traditionally, many of these injuries were managed conservatively through bracing and physical therapy until the individual reached skeletal maturity. Subsequently, a routine adult anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR) was performed at that stage. However, recent evidence suggests that delaying definitive surgery leads to secondary injuries to adjacent structures, such as the meniscus and cartilage, with repeated episodes of instability.2–4 The focus has shifted to early reconstruction in this age group.

ACLR in the skeletally immature individual can be associated with certain complications like injury to the growth plate leading to limb length discrepancies or deformities around the knee.5 With the intention of reducing these risks, different physeal-sparing surgical techniques have been outlined.6,7

A range of graft options has been documented in the literature for ACLR in the pediatric and adolescent population, encompassing the hamstring tendon, quadriceps tendon, patellar tendon, iliotibial band, and various allografts. Each graft presents its own set of advantages and disadvantages.8–11 The HT autograft is the most commonly used one for pediatric ACLR.12 The most common complication following pediatric ACLR is graft rupture, which varies between 10 % and 25 %.13,14 Recently, quadriceps tendon (QT) autograft has gained some popularity due to their relative thickness and high load to failure, resulting in a lower graft rupture rate.10 The current literature has not analyzed the ideal graft choice that should be used in this age group. Our review aimed to assess the complication rates and functional outcomes between two commonly used autografts (HT versus QT) for ACLR in skeletally immature patients. We hypothesized that QT autografts would exhibit greater performance, characterized by lower graft rupture rates and better functional outcomes, compared to HT autografts in the context of ACLR for skeletally immature cohorts.

2

2 Materials and methods

This study was carried out based on a protocol registered in PROSPERO (CRD42022289285).

2.1

2.1 Search methodology

This systematic review adhered to the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis (PRISMA) guidelines. Two independent reviewers (KR and VB) conducted a thorough electronic literature search to identify studies evaluating ACLR in the pediatric population. The PubMed/Medline, Scopus, and Ovid databases were searched up to March 2022. There were no date restrictions. We used the following keywords for the search: "(Paediatric OR pediatric OR adolescent OR skeletally immature) AND (ACL OR (anterior cruciate ligament)) AND (Hamstring OR Quadriceps) AND graft." A bibliography search was conducted within the selected articles to identify additional potential studies that might not have been initially identified in the original search. After applying the inclusion and exclusion criteria, eligible studies were selected for this review.

2.2

2.2 Inclusion and exclusion criteria

Table 1 depicts the inclusion and exclusion criteria that were applied.

Table 1 Inclusion and exclusion criteria used for selecting articles.
Inclusion criteria Exclusion criteria
✓RCTs, cohort studies, case-control studies, and case series✓Studies with a comparison group using Quadriceps and Hamstring autografts OR Case series using Hamstring or Quadriceps autografts in skeletally immature patients (age less than 18 years).✓A minimum follow-up of at least two years ✗Case reports, review articles, and conference abstracts✗ACLR in skeletally mature patients. (Age >18 years)✗Studies that do not report primary outcome parameter – graft rupture rates.✗Studies that used allografts or autografts other than hamstring and quadriceps.✗Animal studies, biomechanical studies, and cadaveric studies✗Studies in languages other than English
2.3

2.3 PICO framework

Participants: Skeletally immature patients undergoing ACLR. Intervention: ACLR using QT autograft. Control: ACLR using HT autograft. Outcomes: Rate of graft rupture and contralateral ACL injury and functional outcomes in terms of patient-reported outcome scores such as the Tegner, Lysholm, Marx, or IKDC scores.

2.4

2.4 Data Extraction

The outcomes of the literature search underwent screening based on the title and abstract, a process carried out independently by two authors (KR and VB). Whenever there was a dispute about an article's eligibility, the complete text was collected, evaluated, and handled by a discussion with all the authors. Two writers (KR and VB) retrieved pertinent data from the papers included in the analysis separately. In case of insufficient data, the corresponding author was contacted with the request to provide the same. Any disputes in data collection were resolved by discussion among all authors until a consensus was reached.

2.5

2.5 Statistical analysis

A pooled analysis of outcomes was performed for all ACLRs done with HT and QT autografts. Heterogeneity in the articles was depicted using the I2 statistic. If I2 was greater than 50 %, we chose a random-effects model, and a fixed-effect model was used in other cases. Statistical significance in this study was assessed utilizing 95 % confidence intervals and a p-value criterion of less than 0.05. The meta-analysis was done with OpenMeta Analyst Windows software (www.cebm.brown.edu/openmeta).

2.6

2.6 Risk of bias

The MINORS (Methodological Index for Non-Randomized Studies) tool was applied by two authors (VB and NR) to assess the included studies' risk of bias independently. The tool comprised eight and twelve items for non-comparative and comparative studies, respectively. Each study's quality was assessed based on the criteria Vivekanantha et al.15 used in their research.

3

3 Results

3.1

3.1 Search outcomes

The combined search yielded a total of 7753 results. Duplicate results were removed, resulting in 5891 articles. The abstracts of these articles were screened, and this led to the elimination of 5867 studies. The full text of the 24 remaining articles was obtained and evaluated for eligibility. A further 12 studies were excluded, as they either did not contain the required outcome parameters (n = 4), or were review articles (n = 2), living donor graft from a parent was used (n = 1), or did not contain separate outcome data on individual grafts used (n = 5). Finally, 12 studies were eligible to be included in the review (Fig. 1).

PRISMA flow diagram.
Fig. 1 PRISMA flow diagram.
3.2

3.2 Study characteristics

Of the twelve included studies, two23,24 were retrospective comparative studies, and of the remaining ten non-comparative studies, eight8,10,16,18–22 were retrospective, while two11,17 were prospective studies (Table 2). Twelve studies had data on 659 patients (QT group: 205; HT group: 454). The participants had a mean age of 13.6 years. It's important to note that all included studies in this review had a minimum follow-up duration of two years. Two comparative studies compared HT and QT autografts, and in the non-comparative group, six studies used HT autografts, and four used QT autografts. Fixation at the femoral and tibial sides was done using either endo-button or interference screws (Table 2). Surgical techniques used in different studies and other parameters are given in detail in Table 2.

Table 2 Summary of the included studies showing demographics and characteristics like graft rupture rates, contralateral ACL injury rates, functional outcomes, RTS, etc.
S. No Author, Published Year, Country/Region Study design No. of cases Mean Age (y) Mean Follow up Gender (M/F) Graft Used for ACL Reconstruction Mean Graft Diameter (mm) Surgical technique Femoral fixation using Tibial fixation using Graft rupture rate ContralateralACL injury rate Associated injuries Return to activity/sports (months) Functional scores at final follow-up Growth disturbances (if any) at the final follow-up
1 Astur et al.,8 2019, Brazil Case-control study; Retrospective 52 13.9 6.2 y 29/23 Quadruple Hamstring tendon Intact ACL group: 7.6 ± 0.7 mm;ACL rupture group: 7.3 ± 0.8 mm Transphyseal isometric or anatomic ACL reconstruction Transfix- 24Button- 08Interference screw- 02 Interference screw- 31Button- 03 34.6 % (18/52) NR Medial meniscal tear – 24 Intact graft- 7.4 (1.0),Graft rupture- 7.5 (1.2) Tegner- 7.0 ± 0.8Lysholm- 90.6 ± 6.1 Nil
2 Cassard et al.,16 2014, France Case series; Retrospective 28 13 (9–15) 2.8 y 20/8 Quadruple Semitendinosus tendon autograft NR Femoral – intraepiphyseal; Tibial side – Transphyseal (TLS system) Interference screw (TLS system) Interference screw (TLS system) 7 % (2/28) NR Lateral meniscus tear – 2Medial meniscal tear – 6 NR Tegner- 8.4Lysholm- 95.4 Nil
3 Cordasco et al.,17 2016, USA Case series; Prospective 23 12.2 32.1 m 17/6 Autograft Hamstring tendon Varied from 7 to 10 mm All inside, all epiphyseal reconstruction Loop suspensory fixation (TightRope) Loop suspensory fixation (TightRope) 8.6 % (2/23) 4.3 % (1/23) Lateral meniscus tear – 7Medial meniscal tear – 3 13.5 (8–22) Lysholm- 97.9 (4.0),IKDC score - 94.6 ± 4.9, Marx score - 13.4 ± 3.6. No significant growth disturbance. However, 6 patients had LLD> 5 mm
4 Hansson et al.,21 2022, Sweden Case control study; Retrospective 193 12.5 6.9 y 75/118 Hamstring tendon autograft Non-revised group: 8.1 ± 0.8 mm; Revision group: 8.1 ± 0.7 mm Transphyseal Endobutton Tibial post screw fixation 12.4 % (24) 11.9 % (23) Lateral meniscus- 60Medial Meniscus- 49MCL- 3Chondral injury- 3 At least 9 months in group 1 and a minimum of 6 months in group 2 KOOS QoL - 67.4 ± 26.0.EQ-5D VAS- 78.2 ± 20.7. NR
5 Kocher et al.,18 2007, USA Case series; Retrospective 59 14.7 3.6 y 23/36 Quadrupled hamstrings-tendon graft 7–10 mm Transphyseal tunnels Endobutton Interference screw 3 % (2/59) NR Lateral meniscus- 25Medial Meniscus- 10 6 months IKDC- 89.5 ± 10.2Lysholm- 91.2 ± 10.7 Nil
6 Wall et al.,20 2017, USA Case series; Retrospective 27 11.4 3.6 y 23/4 Quadruple-hamstring tendon autograft NR All-epiphyseal technique Endobutton Interference screw 15 % (4) 7 % (2) Lateral meniscus- 3Medial meniscus- 2Contralateral medial meniscus tear −1 6–9 months Mean Pedi-IKDC/IKDC - 94 ± 11 Three patients had knee overgrowth; two required a guided growth procedure.
7 Kohl et al.,11 2013, Switzerland Prospective study 15 12.8 ± 2.6 4.1 y 12/3 Quadriceps tendon Autograft 7–9 mm Transphyseal tunnels Interference screw Interference screw 0 NR Lateral meniscus- 6Medial Meniscus- 5 NR Lysholm- Gillquist score - 94.0 (68–100),IKDC 2000 score 13/15 near normal. One case had a valgus deformity
8 Mauch et al.22, 2011, Switzerland Retrospective 49 13 (8–15) 5 y 28/21 Quadriceps tendon – bone Autograft NR Transphyseal tunnels Femoral post screw fixation Tibial post screw fixation 10.2 % (5/49) NR Meniscal injury- 29 6 months but cutting and pivoting sport at 9 months NR One case had a progressive valgus-flexion deformity
9 Vaughn et al.,19 2022, USA Case series; Retrospective 21 15.0 2.8 y 11/10 Quadriceps tendon – bone Autograft 9 mm Transphyseal tunnels Endobutton Endobutton 0 9.5 % (2) Lateral meniscus- 11Medial meniscus- 4Chondral injury- 2 7 months Lysholm- 98 (95–100) Nil
10 Gagliardi et al.,10 2020, USA Case series, retrospective 81 15.9 ± 1.7 3.1Y 42/39 Quadriceps tendon – bone Autograft NR All-epiphyseal (2.5 %), hybrid (46.9 %), or transphyseal technique (50.6 %) Loop suspensory fixation (TightRope) Loop suspensory fixation (TightRope) 1.2 % (1/81) 9.8 % (8/81) NR 87.9 % RTS within 36 months of surgery Pedi-IKDC score- 94 (89–98). Lysholm score- 99.5 (89.0–100.0) NR
11 Pennock et al.,23 2019, USA Retrospective comparative study 56 14.8 ± 1.4 Minimum 2y M > F Hamstring tendon autograft 7.8 mm Transphyseal tunnels Endobutton Screw and post fixation 21 % (12/56) 9 % (5/56) NR 6–12 months Lysholm- 94 ± 6Tegner- 7.1 ± 2.0 No deformity/LLD
27 14.8 ± 1.3 Minimum 2y M > F Quadriceps tendon autograft 9.6 mm Transphyseal tunnels Endobutton Screw and post fixation 4 % (1/27) 19 % (5/27) NR 6–12 months Lysholm- 96 ± 8Tegner- 6.6 ± 1.6 No deformity/LLD
12 Gebhard et al.,24 2006, Multicenter Retrospective comparative study 16 11.9 (7–14) 33 m M > F Hamstring tendon autograft NR Transphyseal tunnels Endobutton Suture disk 0 NR NR NR Lysholm 94.3Tegner 5.9 No deformity/LLD
12 11.9 (7–14) 33 m M > F Quadriceps tendon-bone autograft NR Transphyseal tunnels with bone block in the femoral epiphysis AO screw fixation AO screw fixation 25 % (3/12) NR NR NR Lysholm 94.3Tegner 5.9 No deformity/LLD
3.3

3.3 Risk of bias assessment

As per the MINORS scoring system, nine studies scored 12 out of 16 for non-comparative studies, indicating fair-level evidence quality. One study scored 13 out of 16, showing high-level evidence quality. For comparative studies, one study scored 19 out of 24, indicating good-level evidence quality, and another scored 20 out of 24, indicating high-level evidence quality (Table 3).

Table 3 Quality assessment using the MINORS tool for the included comparative and non-comparative studies.
S.No Study A clearly stated aim Inclusion of consecutive patients Prospective collection of data Endpoints appropriate to the aim of the study Unbiased assessment of the study endpoints Follow-up period appropriate to the aim of the study Loss to follow-up of less than 5 % Prospective calculation of the study size An adequate control group Contemporary groups Baseline equivalence of groups Adequate statistical analysis Total Quality of study assessment
1. Astur et al., 20198 2 1 2 2 1 2 2 0 – – – – 12/16 Fair quality
2. Cassard et al., 201416 2 2 1 2 1 2 2 0 – – – – 12/16 Fair quality
3. Cordasco et al., 201617 2 2 2 2 1 2 2 0 – – – – 13/16 High quality
4. Hansson et al., 202121 2 2 1 2 1 2 2 0 – – – – 12/16 Fair quality
5. Kocher et al., 201318 2 1 2 2 1 2 2 0 – – – – 12/16 Fair quality
6. Wall et al., 201720 2 2 1 2 1 2 2 0 – – – – 12/16 Fair quality
7. Kohl et al., 201311 2 1 2 2 1 2 2 0 – – – – 12/16 Fair quality
8. Mauch et al., 201122 2 2 1 2 1 2 2 0 – – – – 12/16 Fair quality
9. Vaughn et al., 202119 2 1 2 2 1 2 2 0 – – – – 12/16 Fair quality
10. Gagliardi et al., 202010 2 1 2 2 1 2 2 0 – – – – 12/16 Fair quality
11. Pennock et al., 201923 2 1 2 2 1 2 2 0 1 2 2 2 19/24 Good quality
12. Gebhard et al., 200624 2 2 2 2 1 2 2 0 2 2 1 2 20/24 High quality
3.4

3.4 Meta-analysis results

A pooled analysis (meta-analysis) of outcomes was carried out in the twelve included studies, which revealed the following findings:a)Graft rupture rates:

All twelve studies8,10,11,16–24 had data on graft rupture rates in individual autografts (HT and QT). The overall graft rupture rate was 8.8 % (95 % CI 4.8, 12.9). Taking cases operated with QT and HT separately into two groups, the subgroup analysis showed that QT autografts had a significantly lesser graft rupture rate than HT autografts (graft rupture rates 3.5 % [95 % CI 0.2, 6.8] and 12.4 % [95 % CI 6.1, 18.7] respectively, p < 0.001) (Fig. 2).b)Contralateral ACL injury rates:

Forest plot (Pooled analysis) of the studies showing graft rupture rates between HT and QT autografts.
Fig. 2 Forest plot (Pooled analysis) of the studies showing graft rupture rates between HT and QT autografts.

Six studies10,17,19–21,23 had data on the incidence of contralateral ACL injuries following primary ACLR. The contralateral ACL tear rate was 10.2 % (95 % CI 7.3, 13.1). No statistically significant difference between the QT and HT groups was noted in the subgroup analysis. (contralateral ACL injury rates were 11 % [95 % CI 5.6, 16.3] for the QT group and 9.9 % [95 % CI 6.5, 13.3] for the HT group, respectively, p = 0.7) (Fig. 3).c)Functional Outcome Scores:

Forest plot (Pooled analysis) of the studies showing contralateral ACL injury rates between HT and QT autografts.
Fig. 3 Forest plot (Pooled analysis) of the studies showing contralateral ACL injury rates between HT and QT autografts.

Eleven studies8,10,11,16–21,23,24 reported the functional outcome in terms of patient-reported outcome scores, such as the Tegner, Lysholm, Marx, and IKDC/pedi-IKDC scores. At the final follow-up, the mean Tegner scores ranged from 5.9 to 8.4, Lysholm scores from 89.0 to 98.0, IKDC scores from 89 to 94.0, and Marx score 13.4 ± 3.6 [Table 2]. The pooled mean Lysholm score8,10,11,16–19,23,24 at the final follow-up was 95.17 (95 % CI 93.43, 96.91). On subgroup analysis, the score was significantly higher for the QT group than the HT group (p < 0.001) (Fig. 4).d)Growth disturbance rates:

Forest plot (Pooled analysis) of the studies showing mean Lysholm scores between HT and QT autografts.
Fig. 4 Forest plot (Pooled analysis) of the studies showing mean Lysholm scores between HT and QT autografts.

Ten studies8,11,16–20,22–24 documented whether any growth disturbances were noticed at the final follow-up. On subgroup pooled analysis, there was no significant difference between the two groups in terms of angular deformity or limb length discrepancy at final follow-up (LLD) (p = 0.394) (Fig. 5).e)Return to activity/sports:

Forest plot (Pooled analysis) of the studies showing growth disturbance rates between HT and QT autografts.
Fig. 5 Forest plot (Pooled analysis) of the studies showing growth disturbance rates between HT and QT autografts.

The earliest return to pre-injury level activities or sports was reported by Kocher et al.,18 who used HT autograft, wherein patients were allowed to return to sports six months after surgery. Other authors have reported a variable return to sports after surgery, 6–13.5 months (Table 2).f)Incidence of associated injuries at presentation:

A mean of 52.3 % of patients (95 % CI 42.7, 61.7) had associated injuries at presentation (Fig. 6). Although this had no direct relation with graft selection, we looked at the overall associated injury patterns. The injuries included meniscal injuries (medial and lateral), chondral injuries, and medial collateral ligament sprains. Injuries to the lateral meniscus were the most common, accounting for 58.3 % of all associated injuries, followed by medial meniscus injury (39.2 %), chondral injuries (1.6 %), and medial collateral ligament (MCL) injury (0.62 %).

Forest plot (Pooled analysis) of the studies showing associated injury rates.
Fig. 6 Forest plot (Pooled analysis) of the studies showing associated injury rates.
4

4 Discussion

In recent times, there has been a documented rise in the incidence of anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injuries within the pediatric population.25,26 Certain factors predispose individuals in these age groups to an ACL tear, including increased lateral tibial slope, narrow notch, and smaller size of the ACL.27,28 Certain complications are unique to pediatric ACLR, the most important of which is physeal injury that can lead to growth arrest and deformities as the child grows.11,29

Graft rupture or retear remains the most common complication reported in literature following pediatric ACLR,13,30 and it is 2.5–3.5 times higher than adult ACLR.31 According to our review, the incidence of graft rupture was 12.4 % for HT autografts and 3.5 % for QT autografts.

Allografts have a higher and unacceptable graft rupture rate and are not recommended in this age group.30,32 There have been reports that the HT graft is prone to rupture in the pediatric population due to its smaller and variable thickness.33 Some studies have suggested that the removal of hamstrings weakens the dynamic stabilizers of the ACL, making it prone to rupture.34,35 The bone-patellar tendon-bone autograft (BPTB) is frequently regarded as the reference standard in adults.36 However, since this graft is associated with removing bone plugs and potentially placing the bone plugs across the physis, it may not be suitable for patients with open physis. In their recent systematic review, Turati et al.37 documented that BPTB graft can be used in Tanner 3 and 4 patients with 5.2 % graft rupture rates with good clinical outcomes and no growth disturbance or angular deformity. While the graft rupture rates of QT autograft are similar to those of the BPTB autograft, considerations such as knee pain in the anterior aspect, patella fracture risk, and rupture of patellar tendon present in BPTB graft harvest slightly lean in favor of QT autograft over BPTB.38

The QT autograft is a viable alternative that has been used in the past, with reports of its use dating up to two decades ago in skeletally immature age groups.39 Recently, surgeons preferred using QT autografts in contact sports athletes as they contain more collagen with a higher tensile strength40 and preserve hamstring functions. Few recent studies have evaluated the outcomes of the QT graft, and most of them have reported favourable graft rupture rates compared to the literature on HT grafts.11,19,22 A systematic review recently conducted by Zakharia et al.41 explored the outcomes of QT autografts in pediatric ACLR. They reported that QT grafts were associated with a promising functional outcome, good rates of return to sports, and a low complication rate. Unlike this study, they reviewed only studies with QT grafts and did not make any comparison with HT grafts. Our analysis indicates that QT autografts have comparatively lesser rupture rates compared to HT grafts.

Regarding graft size, Pennock et al.,23 in their comparative study of HT and QT autografts, observed that quadriceps tendons had more thickness than HT autografts with up to 60 % bigger cross-sections; QT autografts (9.6 mm) were larger in diameter than HT autografts (7.8 mm) with a p-value < 0.001.23 They also noted that this thick QT autograft was linked to a significantly lesser rate of graft ruptures than HT autografts. (4 % vs 21 %, respectively; P = 0.037). Baghdadi et al.42 did a pre-operative MRI in 169 patients with a mean age of 15 years and their research indicated that having an MRI quadriceps sagittal thickness exceeding 6.7 mm exhibited a sensitivity of 97.4 % in predicting a final graft size equal to or greater than 8 mm. While larger drill holes in the femur and tibia were needed to accommodate this larger QT graft, no significant growth disturbances or angular deformities were noted.42 Also, our analysis showed no significant growth disturbances between HT and QT autograft groups.

Regarding the relationship between different surgical techniques (all epiphyseal and transphyseal) and graft survival rates, DeFrancesco et al.9 published the most extensive series on pediatric ACLR, involving a total of 996 patients, and they analyzed four-year graft rupture-free survival of mainly HT autografts (87 % of the study population) by Kaplan-Meier survival curves. They found transphyseal ACLR in the age group <16 years have more graft rupture rates in comparison to all epiphyseal ACLR and transphyseal ACLR (in the age group of >16 years) techniques; the reason may be increased activities during adolescent age group (<16 years). The area of improvisation in the future can be the fixation techniques. Based on our review, in QT autografts, suspensory fixation on the femoral side and a screw and post-fixation on the tibial side is usually sufficient. With the bone block in the QT graft, one may get a longer graft and a more predictable fixation using screws. In our review, four studies used QT-bone graft, and two used QT autograft without bone block. The functional outcome is comparable between the two subgroups (QT tendon alone vs. QT tendon with bone) with statistically insignificant graft rupture rate between QT tendon with bone and without bone (graft rupture rates 4.6 % [95 % CI 0.8, 1.0] and 3.5 % [95 % CI 2.0, 8.9] respectively, p = 0.181) (Fig. 7).

Forest plot of QT group studies showing graft rupture rates between those with and without bone blocks.
Fig. 7 Forest plot of QT group studies showing graft rupture rates between those with and without bone blocks.

There are certain issues with harvesting a quadriceps tendon graft. Since the procedure is invasive to the extensor mechanism, it has been reported to lead to initial extensor weakness.33,43 On the other hand, recent reports have suggested that full extensor function may be regained with proper physical therapy after harvesting the QT graft.44 Another reported complication is the development of post-operative arthrofibrosis that may necessitate manipulation under anaesthesia.45,46 The reasons for the development of arthrofibrosis may be reduced quadriceps firing due to harvest, increased stiffness of the quadriceps graft, or the enlarged size of the graft causing impingement in the intercondylar notch during extension.46

Contralateral ACL injuries following ACLR are threefold more common in skeletally immature populations than in adults.31 Females are three times more predisposed to a contralateral ACL injury than their male counterparts.47 Contralateral ACL injury rates are comparable between the HT and QT groups.

Different authors used different functional outcome scores in their studies, such as Tegner, IKDC, Lysholm, and Marx scores. Based on our results, the QT group had better post-operative functional outcome scores in terms of mean Lysholm scores at the terminal follow-up than the HT group. The preinjury functional outcome scores were not documented in all the included studies, so we did not assess the improvement following ACLR compared to preinjury status. Astur et al.8 found that those cases who sustained ACL re-ruptures demonstrated decreased Tegner and Lysholm scores while returning to sports than those who did not have ACL re-ruptures.

Based on our review, return to sports (RTS) has been variably allowed from 6 to 13.5 months. Due to insufficient data, we could not draw comparisons between QT and HT autografts. Biomechanical studies48 showed that at 4–6 months following ACLR, the collagen contents in HT autografts were relatively lower compared to native ACL. It started increasing after 5–7 months and reached a comparable level with native ACL at 11–13 months only.48 Due to the increasing participation in highly competitive sports in the skeletally immature age group, thicker grafts like QT autograft containing high collagen content look like a better option with a possible early RTS. In a comparative study conducted by Runer et al.,38 encompassing both children and adult populations and comparing QT and hamstring tendon (HT) autografts, it was documented that, overall, 72 % (n = 345) of participants returned to preinjury activity levels. Importantly, no significant difference was observed between QT and HT autografts (QT, 66.7 %; HT, 73.7 %, p = 0.14) at the 2-year follow-up. It has been shown in previous studies that a delay in RTS to 9 months and one year would lead to lower retear rates compared to RTS at six months.31 Dekker et al.,49 who used HT autograft in most cases in pediatric ACLR, found an association between a quicker return to sports and a graft rupture risk, with the slower return being protective. Based on our review, we cannot find a clear-cut association between graft rupture and the time interval for RTS.

This review is not without limitations. A lack of higher-level evidence studies like RCT and prospective cohort studies is evident. We only focused on the two commonly used autografts (HT versus QT) and didn't include other graft options like BPTB, Iliotibial band, or other soft tissue auto/allografts for comparison. Other limitations are that different surgical techniques and fixation methods were used in the included studies and the heterogeneity of the involved studies. There was insufficient data on return to sports with no uniform consensus guidelines regarding timing, clearance criteria, and neuromuscular conditioning in return to same-level sports among HT and QT groups. The cohort of highly competitive athletes involved in pivoting and cutting sports needs to be analyzed separately, but the included studies have no separate data.

However, the study's strength is that ours is the first meta-analysis comparing the QT autograft with the commonly used HT autograft in skeletally immature cohorts undergoing ACLR. It's emphasized that all the studies included in the analysis adhere to a minimum follow-up duration of 2 years. The graft choice remains a point of contentious debate among arthroscopy surgeons in pediatric ACLR. This paper tried to answer the same systematically from the available limited evidence studies published in the literature till now.

5

5 Conclusion

In skeletally immature individuals undergoing ACLR, QT autograft yields promising outcomes characterized by lower graft rupture rates and better functional outcomes with similar contralateral ACL injury and growth disturbance rates relative to the commonly used HT autograft, which is supported by limited quality of studies. Further research is justified into the efficacy of quadriceps autograft in pediatric ACLR through multicentric randomized trials with clear-cut RTS criteria.

Ethical standard statement

As this is a systematic review of literature data, approval by the Institutional Ethics Committee was deemed unnecessary. But the departmental review board approval was obtained [DRB/Ortho/2023/22].

Source of funding

Nil. None of the authors received financial support for this study.

Consent to participate

Not applicable as it is a systematic review and did not involve direct patient care.

Consent to publish

Not applicable as it is a systematic review and did not involve direct patient care.

Parent/Guardian consent to participate

Not applicable as it is a systematic review and does not involve direct patient care.

CRediT authorship contribution statement

Karthick Rangasamy: Conceptualization, and design of work, Article selection, Manuscript, Writing – original draft, Systematic review, and Critical revision. Vishnu Baburaj: , Article selection, Manuscript, Writing – original draft, and, Data curation, Formal analysis. Nirmal Raj Gopinathan: Manuscript, Writing – original draft, Data curation, and, Supervision. Mandeep Singh Dhillon: Critical revision of the manuscript. Shital N. Parikh: Critical revision of the manuscript.

References

  1. , , , , . Trends in pediatric and adolescent anterior cruciate ligament injury and reconstruction. J Pediatr Orthop. 2016;36(5):447-452.
    [Google Scholar]
  2. , , , , . Long-term clinical and radiographic results after delayed anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction in adolescents. Am J Sports Med. 2015;43(1):138-145.
    [Google Scholar]
  3. , , , . Associated injuries in pediatric and adolescent anterior cruciate ligament tears: does a delay in treatment increase the risk of meniscal tear? Arthroscopy. 2002;18(9):955-959.
    [Google Scholar]
  4. , , , et al . Factors predictive of concomitant injuries among children and adolescents undergoing anterior cruciate ligament surgery. Am J Sports Med. 2015;43(2):282-288.
    [Google Scholar]
  5. , , , , . Management and complications of anterior cruciate ligament injuries in skeletally immature patients: survey of the Herodicus Society and the ACL Study Group. J Pediatr Orthop. 2002;22(4):452-457.
    [Google Scholar]
  6. , , , . Physeal sparing reconstruction of the anterior cruciate ligament in skeletally immature prepubescent children and adolescents. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2005;87(11):2371-2379.
    [Google Scholar]
  7. , , , , . Surgical options for anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction in the young child. Curr Opin Pediatr. 2015;27(1):82-91.
    [Google Scholar]
  8. , , , et al . Pediatric anterior cruciate ligament reruptures are related to lower functional scores at the time of return to activity: a prospective, midterm follow-up study. Orthop J Sports Med. 2019;7(12)
    [Google Scholar]
  9. , , , , , . An in-depth analysis of graft rupture and contralateral anterior cruciate ligament rupture rates after pediatric anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. Am J Sports Med. 2020;48(10):2395-2400.
    [Google Scholar]
  10. , , , , . Outcomes of quadriceps tendon with patellar bone block anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction in adolescent patients with a minimum 2-year follow-up. Am J Sports Med. 2020;48(1):93-98.
    [Google Scholar]
  11. , , , et al . Mid-term results of transphyseal anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction in children and adolescents. Knee. 2014;21(1):80-85.
    [Google Scholar]
  12. , , , , , , . Graft choices for paediatric anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction: state of the art. J ISAKOS. 2023 Jun;8(3):145-152.
    [Google Scholar]
  13. , , , . Complications after pediatric ACL reconstruction: a meta-analysis. J Pediatr Orthop. 2017;39(8):e566-e571.
    [Google Scholar]
  14. , , , et al . Secondary injuries after pediatric anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction: a systematic review with quantitative analysis. Am J Sports Med. 2021;49(4):1086-1093.
    [Google Scholar]
  15. , , , et al . Tibial tubercle to trochlear groove distance versus tibial tubercle to posterior cruciate ligament distance for predicting patellar instability: a systematic review. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc 2023 Mar 6
    [Google Scholar]
  16. , , , , . Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction in children with a quadrupled semitendinosus graft: preliminary results with minimum 2 years of follow-up. J Pediatr Orthop. 2014;34(1):70-77.
    [Google Scholar]
  17. , , , . All-inside, all-epiphyseal anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction in skeletally immature athletes: return to sport, incidence of second surgery, and 2-year clinical outcomes. Am J Sports Med. 2017;45(4):856-863.
    [Google Scholar]
  18. , , , , , . Transphyseal anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction in skeletally immature pubescent adolescents. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2007;89(12):2632-2639.
    [Google Scholar]
  19. , , , , . The outcomes of quadriceps tendon autograft for anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction in adolescent athletes: a retrospective case series. Eur J Orthop Surg Traumatol. 2022;32(4):739-744.
    [Google Scholar]
  20. , , , , , . Outcomes and complications after all-epiphyseal anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction in skeletally immature patients. Orthop J Sports Med. 2017;5(3)
    [Google Scholar]
  21. , , , , , . Long-term evaluation of pediatric ACL reconstruction: high risk of further surgery but a restrictive post-operative management was related to a lower revision rate. Arch Orthop Trauma Surg. 2022;142(8):1951-1961.
    [Google Scholar]
  22. , , , , , , . Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction using quadriceps tendon autograft for adolescents with open physes- a technical note. Sports Med Arthrosc Rehabil Ther Technol. 2011;3(1):7.
    [Google Scholar]
  23. , , , et al . Transphyseal anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction in the skeletally immature: quadriceps tendon autograft versus hamstring tendon autograft. Orthop J Sports Med. 2019;7(9)
    [Google Scholar]
  24. , , , , , . Multicenter-study of operative treatment of intraligamentous tears of the anterior cruciate ligament in children and adolescents: comparison of four different techniques. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc. 2006;14(9):797-803.
    [Google Scholar]
  25. , , , , . Paediatric injuries around the knee: soft tissue injuries. Injury. 2022;53(2):237-243.
    [Google Scholar]
  26. , , , . Epidemiology and diagnosis of anterior cruciate ligament injuries. Clin Sports Med. 2017;36(1):1-8.
    [Google Scholar]
  27. , , , et al . Knee morphological risk factors for anterior cruciate ligament injury: a systematic review. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2020;102(8):703-718.
    [Google Scholar]
  28. , , , et al . Increased lateral tibial slope is a risk factor for pediatric anterior cruciate ligament injury: an MRI-based case-control study of 152 patients. Am J Sports Med. 2015;43(7):1632-1639.
    [Google Scholar]
  29. , , , et al . Tibial tunnel defect size as a risk factor in growth arrest following paediatric transphyseal anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction: an anatomical study. ANZ J Surg. 2016;86(9):691-695.
    [Google Scholar]
  30. , , . Pediatric anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction outcomes. Curr Rev Musculoskelet Med. 2016;9(4):339-347.
    [Google Scholar]
  31. , , , , . Paediatric anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injuries: current concepts review. Indian J Orthop. 2022;56(6):952-962.
    [Google Scholar]
  32. , , , , , . Comparison of allograft versus autograft anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction graft survival in an active adolescent cohort. Am J Sports Med. 2014;42(10):2311-2318.
    [Google Scholar]
  33. , , , et al . Does allograft augmentation of small-diameter hamstring autograft ACL grafts reduce the incidence of graft retear? Am J Sports Med. 2017;45(2):334-338.
    [Google Scholar]
  34. , , , , , , . The evaluation of muscle recovery after anatomical single-bundle ACL reconstruction using a quadriceps autograft. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc. 2017;25(5):1449-1453.
    [Google Scholar]
  35. , , , et al . Strength recovery after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with quadriceps tendon versus hamstring tendon autografts in soccer players: a randomized controlled trial. Knee. 2018;25(4):704-714.
    [Google Scholar]
  36. , , , . Outcomes following ACL reconstruction based on graft type: are all grafts equivalent? Curr Rev Musculoskelet Med. 2019;12(4):460-465.
    [Google Scholar]
  37. , , , et al . Clinical outcomes and complications after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with bone-patellar tendon-bone in patient Tanner 3 and 4: a systematic review. Eur J Orthop Surg Traumatol 2022 Oct 29
    [Google Scholar]
  38. , , , , , , . Anterior cruciate ligament reconstructions with quadriceps tendon autograft result in lower graft rupture rates but similar patient-reported outcomes as compared with hamstring tendon autograft: a comparison of 875 patients. Am J Sports Med. 2020;48(9):2195-2204.
    [Google Scholar]
  39. , , , , . The outcome of operatively treated anterior cruciate ligament disruptions in the skeletally immature child. Arthroscopy. 1997;13(5):627-634.
    [Google Scholar]
  40. , , , , , . Biomechanical considerations for graft choice in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. Annals of Joint [Online]. 2023;8
    [Google Scholar]
  41. , , , et al . Quadriceps tendon autograft for pediatric anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction results in promising post-operative function and rates of return to sports: a systematic review. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc. 2022 Nov;30(11):3659-3672.
    [Google Scholar]
  42. , , , et al . Quadriceps tendon autograft in pediatric ACL reconstruction: graft dimensions and prediction of size on preoperative MRI. Orthop J Sports Med. 2021 Dec 15;9(12)
    [Google Scholar]
  43. , , , et al . Higher hamstring-to-quadriceps isokinetic strength ratio during the first post-operative months in patients with quadriceps tendon compared to hamstring tendon graft following ACL reconstruction. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc. 2018;26(2):418-425.
    [Google Scholar]
  44. , , , , , , . Is quadriceps tendon autograft a better choice than hamstring autograft for anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction? A comparative study with a mean follow-up of 3.6 years. Am J Sports Med. 2017;45(6):1326-1332.
    [Google Scholar]
  45. , , , , . Predictors of arthrofibrosis after pediatric anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction: what is the impact of quadriceps autograft? J Pediatr Orthop. 2021 Aug 1;41(7):395-399.
    [Google Scholar]
  46. , , , et al . Risk factors for manipulation under anesthesia and/or lysis of adhesions after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. Orthop J Sports Med. 2018;6(9)
    [Google Scholar]
  47. , , , et al . Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction in skeletally immature patients : a systematic review. Bone Joint Lett J. 2017;99-B(8):1053-1060.
    [Google Scholar]
  48. , , , , . The "ligamentization" process in human anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with autogenous patellar and hamstring tendons: a biochemical study. Am J Sports Med. 2005;33:1166-1173.
    [Google Scholar]
  49. , , , , , , . Return to sport after pediatric anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction and its effect on subsequent anterior cruciate ligament injury. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2017;99(11):897-904.
    [Google Scholar]
Show Sections