Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors
Search in posts
Search in pages
Filter by Categories
Case Report
Clinical research study
Current Issue
Editorial Board
Literature Review
Narrative review
Original Article
Research Article
Review Article
Short Report
Surgical techniques
Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis
Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors
Search in posts
Search in pages
Filter by Categories
Case Report
Clinical research study
Current Issue
Editorial Board
Literature Review
Narrative review
Original Article
Research Article
Review Article
Short Report
Surgical techniques
Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis
View/Download PDF
48 (); 6-12
doi:
10.1016/j.jor.2023.11.032

Translate:

Intrawound navigation for custom-made acetabular component in revision total hip arthroplasty: Does it improve implant positioning?

Author affiliations
Vreden National Medical Research Center of Traumatology and Orthopedics, Ministry of Health of Russian Federation, St. Petersburg, Russian Federation
Article History
Corresponding author(s)

∗Corresponding author: Alisagib A. Dzhavadov. alisagib.dzhavadov@gmail.com

Article tools · PDF & citations

Abstract

Abstract

The number of hip revisions makes up over 12 % of all hip arthroplasty cases. For large acetabular defects custom-made acetabular component (CMAC) are required. Rates of malposition of CMACs are highly variable. Our study aims to develop a readily available, reliable and easily reproducible method for positioning of the CMAC. We tried to answer the following questions: 1) how often does the postoperative position of the implant corresponds to the planned one; 2) is the use of intrawound navigation improve the precision of acetabular implant position.

This was a single-center observational cohort study and included two groups: the experimental group (use of 3D navigation for implant positioning) and the control group (no navigation use). All the patients were scheduled for acetabular revision surgery with custom-made 3D-printed acetabular components. All surgeries took place between 2016 and 2020.

25 % freehand group, 85 % implants in the navigation group matched accuracy positioning criteria. The relative risk of malposition was significantly higher without the intraoperative navigation, with 5 times greater risk of malpositioning in the freehand group versus the navigation group.

Navigation method allows planning of the implant and reamer sizes for optimal bone preparation and preservation. It provides easier implantation of the complex implant with reliable, stable primary fixation in massive bone defects. It reliably decreases malposition rate, allowing for implant placement in a proper position with sufficient bone-implant contact. Further research is needed to determine the relationship between CMAC position accuracy and long-term clinical and radiographic outcomes.

Keywords

  • Custom-made acetabular implants
  • Hip joint
  • Revision total hip arthroplasty
  • Standard acetabular implants
  • Three-dimensional imaging
Disclaimer:
This article was originally published by Reed Elsevier India Pvt. Ltd. and was migrated to Scientific Scholar after the change of Publisher.
1

1 Introduction

The number of primary hip arthroplasties is growing, thus leading to increasing hip revisions as well. Hip revisions make up over 12 % of all hip arthroplasty cases.1 Although there are only 1–4% of gross acetabular defects, they present a substantial challenge.2–4 There are many options available for acetabular reconstruction during revision hip arthroplasty. Vast majority of these cases can be managed with “off-the-shell” implants to achieve stable fixation irrespective of patient's possible altered anatomy.5–10 In some situations, however, other options such as custom-made acetabular component (CMAC) for large acetabular defects are required.11–13

In our practice, if acetabular reconstruction is necessary for Paprovsky II-III defects, we chose to use CMAC manufactured by the local certified medical company. Relying on the CT scan, these implants are developed based on the analysis of the shape, quality of the bone, and location of the bone defect. Implantation of these components present significant technical challenges despite patient specific nature. Several publications have compared actual versus planned CMAC positions. Reported rates of malposition of CMACs range from 44 to 75 %.14–17 Our study aims to develop a readily available, reliable and easily reproducible method for positioning of the custom-made acetabular implants. Furthermore, we tried to answer the following questions: 1) how often does the postoperative position of the implant corresponds to the planned one; 2) is the use of intrawound navigation improve the precision of acetabular implant position.

2

2 Materials and methods

2.1

2.1 Study design

This was a single-center observational cohort study. Inclusion criteria were: Paprosky II-III acetabular bone defect, massive uncontained defects or pelvic discontinuity. All the patients were scheduled for acetabular revision surgery with custom-made 3D-printed acetabular components. All surgeries took place between 2016 and 2020.

2.2

2.2 Custom-made acetabular component (CMAC)

Each patient had a routine pre- and postoperative CT scan. Based on the preoperative CT scan, we determinate the center of rotation (COR), optimal implant inclination (INCL), and anteversion (AV) (Fig. 1). Thus, the CT scan data was used to assess the defect, produce a 3D-printed bone defect model, an implant trial model, drill guides, and finally, a patient-specific acetabular titanium implant.

Measurements of COR, orientation (inclination and anteversion) of CMAC hemispherical part. A – assessment of COR height, lateralization and inclination of planned CMAC position, B – assessment of COR height, lateralization and inclination of real CMAC position. C – assessment of COR depth and anteversion of planned CMAC position, D – assessment of COR depth and anteversion of real CMAC position.
Fig. 1 Measurements of COR, orientation (inclination and anteversion) of CMAC hemispherical part. A – assessment of COR height, lateralization and inclination of planned CMAC position, B – assessment of COR height, lateralization and inclination of real CMAC position. C – assessment of COR depth and anteversion of planned CMAC position, D – assessment of COR depth and anteversion of real CMAC position.

Software from Materialise (Mimics Innovation Suite, Materialise NV, Leuven, Belgium) was used for processing of the CT data, segmentation, design implants and postoperative position assessment. CT images were reviewed to assign a Paprosky classification for each acetabular defect. In addition, the CT scan results were used to plan the length and direction of each screw to design flanges on the ilium, pubic and ischial bones and intraileum stem if necessary. Different implant design types were used. Custom-made hemispherical cups and augments with extended fixation options were implanted for contained acetabular defects with preserved both columns and medial wall. For more severe uncontained bone defects a triflanged components or stemmed flanged cups were utilized. A more detailed implant design description was reported in the previous study.18

To achieve optimal contact with the bone and the possibility of custom-made implant fixation, surgeons were involved in bone defect evaluation, design and positioning of the implant during preoperative planning.

2.3

2.3 Intrawound navigation design and method of intrawound navigation

Intrawound navigation set was designed in Materialise Software (Mimics Innovation Suite, Materialise NV, Leuven, Belgium). It included a 3D printed plastic acetabular region, an imprint of native bone landscape surface that would be exposited during the surgery and a reamer guide. There were two channels for K-wire in the part of the imprint that would come in contact with the untreated bone part. After placement of the two K-wires, the imprint was removed and reamer guide placed onto the bone surface along the K-wires. Part of the bone that should be removed was treated with proper size reamer with orientation and till depth marked on the reamer guide. When necessary, there were two or more reamer guides used in sequential manner. Then reamer guide was removed, and CMAC was placed along K-wires. Finally, K-wires were removed if CMAC had good contact with bone and CMAC fixed with screws.

As the intrawound navigation sequence consists of imprint placement, K-wires insertion, and then using reamer guides, the critical step is proper imprint placement. For correct imprint placement, it is necessary to recognize defect borders and landmarks such as the ones represented on a plastic model of the bone defect. There is a high probability of placing an imprint incorrectly if a minor error is made during this step. This will lead to K-wires and reamer guide malpositioning which, in turn, will result in inappropriate implant placement. For this reason, navigation can provide a failsafe.

Elements of navigation should be compact and not restrict manipulation in a wound, all the while providing a consistent and reliable implant placement. For this reason, we should evaluate the navigation elements “through the wound by the surgeon's eyes” when designing navigation. Imprint, the first navigation element, should have a complex surface to only allow for one possible placement position. However, this may still present a challenge if the bone surface is plain or cannot be reconstructed precisely during the segmentation stage. The imprint should be easy to remove after the K-wires setting. Furthermore, as the reamer guide points at inclination and anteversion of the acetabular component, depth of reaming, and determining the reamer position during bone surface preparation, the reamer guide shape and size should not interfere with the process of reaming.

2.4

2.4 Participants

This study included two groups: the experimental group (i.e. use of 3D navigation for implant positioning) and the control group (no navigation use). The control « freehand » group included 20 patients (18 women and two men) (Table 1) at the mean age of 53. The experimental « navigation » group included 20 patients (15 women and five men) at the mean age of 55. (Table 1). There were three types of implants in the first group and four types of implants in the second group (Table 1).

Table 1 Patient's, acetabular defect's and used implant's characteristics.
Variable Free hand group Navigation group
No. of patients 20 20
Mean age (range) 53 (22–72) 55 (27–81)
Sex (M:F) 2:18 5:15
Mean BMI (range) 28 (22–40) 29 (20–43)
Defect types:
Paprosky's 2B 4 1
Paprosky's 2C 2 2
Paprosky's 3A 5 4
Paprosky's 3B 6 8
Discontinuity 3 5
Used custom implant types:
hemispherical cup 4 1
augment 7 1
triflanged component 9 11
stemmed flanged cup 0 7

Most common acetabular defects was Paprosky type 3 in both the freehand group (11 defects) and navigation group (12 defects). CMACs were often designed as triflange components in both the freehand group (9 implants) and navigation group (11 implants). (Table 1).

2.5

2.5 Surgical treatment

According to the preoperative plan, the bone was prepared, and the osteophytes were removed, when necessary. Bone defects were treated with allograft. For patients from the control group, osteophytes removal was performed without a reamer guide by “freehand” technique. For the patients in the navigation group, intraoperative plastic navigation was used. It consisted of imprint and reamer guides. The imprint was designed from 3D reconstruction of the native bone defect margin and had two parts of surface: one surface of the bone planned to be removed and another surface of bone that should be saved to have contact with CMAC flange. The imprint was designed to have a single unique position on the bony surface. After imprint placement, two parallel K-wire were set through the imprint K-wire channels into the bone (Fig. 2). Then the imprint was removed and a reamer guide placed on the bony surface upon previously placed K-wires (Fig. 3). When necessary, two or more reamer guides were used. Once reaming was completed, the reamer guide and K-wires were removed.

Native acetabular defect and fixed on it imprint with K-wires.
Fig. 2 Native acetabular defect and fixed on it imprint with K-wires.
Reamer guiders placed upon K-wires.
Fig. 3 Reamer guiders placed upon K-wires.

In both patient groups, implant trial models were used as a template for the titanium implants. After positioning the individual implant, it was fixed with screws through the provided holes in the augments, cups or flanges (Fig. 4). A surgeon could change the acetabular liner orientation to increase hip joint stability if necessary. The Muller cemented cup (Zimmer, Warsaw, Indiana, USA) was cemented. After surgery, a postoperative CT was performed while the patient was still in the hospital. Postoperatively weight-bearing as tolerated was allowed. Three doses of systemic sultasin were given as perioperative prophylaxis. Low molecular weight heparin was given postoperatively for three days, then changed to oral anticoagulants for four additional weeks if the patient had a history of thromboembolic risk factors. Patient charts were reviewed for intraoperative and postoperative complications.

Reamed acetabular defect and custom-made implant placed upon K-wires.
Fig. 4 Reamed acetabular defect and custom-made implant placed upon K-wires.
2.6

2.6 CT analysis and evaluation

The postoperative position of the implant was compared with the preoperative planning based on a CT scan. 3D pelvis and implanted CMAC reconstruction were performed for each patient. Then, 3D pelvis with implanted CMAC reconstruction overlayed on preoperative 3d pelvis reconstruction to allow for direct comparison (Fig. 5).

Comparison differences (Δ) degrees between planned and postoperative inclination and anteversion of custom-made acetabular components within freehand and navigation implantation method groups.
Fig. 5 Comparison differences (Δ) degrees between planned and postoperative inclination and anteversion of custom-made acetabular components within freehand and navigation implantation method groups.

To minimize the difference between pre-and postoperative implant positions of the pelvic models, an iterative algorithm was used by comparing the nearest points. Center of rotation (COR), implant inclination (INCL), and anteversion (AV) were assessed by comparing the 3D pelvic model on pre-and postoperative CT scans. For the position analysis, the difference between these 2 measurements was calculated. The same software was used for analysis of all CT scans (Mimics Innovation Suite, Materialise NV, Leuven, Belgium).

INCL was measured as the deviation angle of the individual component hemispherical part from the line connecting the “teardrop signs” in the frontal plane, AV was measured as the deviation angle of the individual component hemispherical part from the sagittal plane. The COR position was measured as the distance of its coordinates from the frontal, sagittal, and horizontal planes. Then the difference between pre- and postoperative INCL, AV and ROM values was calculated for each axis (Fig. 5). This was done based on prior description by Baauw et al. Finally, measurements of absolute distances between planned COR and postoperative position of CMAC COR was done for both groups.

As we were interested in an actual CMAC deviation from the planned position, we assessed the absolute value of differences between actual and planned CMAC positions. Sign of values was not considered. Deviation more than 10° from the optimal position of the acetabular component for AV and INCL was considered clinically relevant. Thus, a range of ±10° was adopted as a measure of conformity of the installed structure with the planned one. The COR displacement of more than 5 mm in any direction was also regarded as an excessive displacement of the component.

2.7

2.7 Statistics

Due to the small number of patients in each group, descriptive statistics were used as a number of the data range, median, and interquartile range (IQR). Mann-Whitney nonparametrical test was used for comparison of implant positioning accuracy differences between groups. Relative risk was assessed to get CMAC malposition without navigation use. Statistical analysis was performed in Past 4.03 software.

3

3 Results

Five of twenty (25 %) freehand group implants matched accuracy positioning criteria. The most variable parameters were AV, lateralization and height of COR (Table 2). 17 (85 %) implants matched to accuracy criteria in the navigation group. The relative risk of malposition was significantly higher without the intraoperative navigation, with 5 times greater risk of malpositioning in the freehand group versus the navigation group (RR = 5; CI 95 % [1,7–14,6]; p = 0,003).

Table 2 Differences of measurements between planned and postoperative position of CMAC.
Free hand group(n = 20) Navigation group(n = 20)
Min-Max Mean ± Std.dev IRQ (25–75) Min-Max Mean ± Std.dev IRQ (25–75)
Δ°inclination 0-10,1 3,7 ± 3,0 1,1–5,7 0,8–9,4 3,6 ± 2,9 1,3–5,4
Δ° anteversion 0,1–43,9 13,4 ± 13,1 3,3–18,1 0,1–9,8 4,1 ± 2,8 1,6–5,6
Δ mm X axis (lateralization) 0,2–19,9 4,7 ± 4,4 1,3–6,4 0-7,7 2,1 ± 2,0 0,6–3,2
Δ mm Z axis (height) 0,3–28,9 5,0 ± 6,6 1,0–7,9 0-4,6 2,1 ± 1,5 0,5–3,5
Δ mm Y axis (depth) 0-10,9 3,4 ± 2,5 1,3–5,0 0-8,1 2,1 ± 1,8 1,2–3,0

While AV and INCL values were in the acceptable accuracy range in the navigation group, the same was not seen in the freehand group (Fig. 5). Mean AV differences between planned value and postoperative position were 13.4° for the freehand group and 4.1° for the navigation group, which was statistically significant (p < 0.01).

Mean differences of the distance between planned COR and postoperative position of CMAC COR were 8.8 mm for the freehand group and 4.3 mm for the navigation group (p < 0.01) (Fig. 6). As shown in the image below*, placement of CMAC in the acceptable accuracy range in the freehand group was significantly less than the navigation group.

Distance in mm between planned (central zero point) COR and postoperative position of CMAC COR within freehand and navigation groups.
Fig. 6 Distance in mm between planned (central zero point) COR and postoperative position of CMAC COR within freehand and navigation groups.

During the follow-up period, no patients experienced any dislocation events. Two patients (one with a massive three-flange design and the other with a maximum displacement of the individual augment in height (28.9 mm) and prolapse of the implant into the soft tissues) from the freehand group, required evacuation of the post-operative hematoma without need for revision of the implants. No infections were noted.

4

4 Discussion

Currently, there are numerous publications related to acetabular reconstruction in hip revision surgery using custom-made acetabular components (CMAC).11–13 CMAC can provide an extended bone-implant surface contact and screw fixation, surface adaptation and bone preservation. Moreover, CMAC can be helpful in the reconstruction of complex bone defects. With that said, there are technical difficulties associated with positioning of the CMAC. Commonly CMAC is used for large acetabular defects reconstruction. Extended flanges and surfaces can lead to difficulty with precise placement according to the preoperative plan. While pre-op computer modeling allows setting the component and screw fixation elements at virtually any bony location, intra-operatively the surgeon is limited in his action by wound space and surrounding anatomical structures.

There are few publications about accuracy assessment of postoperative custom acetabular implant position compared to the planned pre-operative positioning. Baauw and Weber declared high accuracy of custom acetabular implant positioning with the freehand technique14,15 by using 10° and 5 mm COR range deviation from the planned position as an acceptable deviation from the actual implant position. Seven of sixteen (44 %) implants were malpositioned in one or more parameters in Baauw et al. study.14 One of the malpositioned implants led to intraoperative pelvic fracture during implantation.

Weber et al. had 7 of 11 (63 %) malpositioned custom-made acetabular implants in one or more parameters.15 Tikhilov et al. study showed that 15 of 20 (75 %) CMACs were placed out of the acceptable deviation range in the most extensive patient series.16 Zampelis V. and Flivik G. showed in their recent study that at least 4 CMACs were set with angular deviation of more than 10°, and 3 CMACs were placed with more than 5 mm displacement leading to a 70 % malposition rate with the freehand technique.17

While a high malposition rate did not result in increased rate of complications based on the available data, CMAC positioning must more closely mimic pre-operative ideal position. The method presented in this paper reduces the CMAC positioning error rate to 15 %.

4.1

4.1 Limitations

There are several limitations of the current study. First, a retrospective study design was used. To reduce potential bias, a consecutive series of patients were included. Second, the study is limited based on low number of patients. Nonetheless, our series is the largest among publications related to this problem with postoperative CT three-dimensional positioning assessment. Third, there were four hemispherical cups and seven augments in the freehand group. They allowed more degrees of freedom for acetabular component positioning, and thus it should be considered during CMAC implantation without navigation. Finally, while we do not have patient reported outcomes to support improved implant position would lead to improved clinical outcomes, this was not the goal of this study. We aimed to demonstrate a more reliable method of implant placement as compared to pre-operative templating.

The suggested intrawound navigation has several disadvantages. Acetabular defect borders and margins could be reconstructed with errors of bone defect landscape. Sources of such mistakes are metal artefacts, high bone density range, altered anatomy, or radiologist or bioengineer experience. Imprint placement also can present some challenges, especially when the bone landscape is uniform without defining features. In such cases, a surgeon should compare the imprint position on the native bone in the wound and on the acetabular plastic model. Large soft tissue envelop can change the direction of the guide pins and instruments for the bony preparation and placement of CMAC in obese patients.

5

5 Conclusion

Navigation method allows planning of the implant and reamer sizes for optimal bone preparation and preservation. This technique allows for a relatively easy set up and subsequent insertion of complex modular implant, such as a stemmed flanged cups consisting of several elements that would then be connected in the wound. It provides easier implantation of the complex implant with reliable, stable primary fixation in massive bone defects.

We should also understand limitations that prevent us from reaching absolute accuracy. They start from bone defect segmentation errors, implant and navigation modelling, and manufacturing errors, including intraoperative bone resection, imprint misplacement, and bone underreaming. Nonetheless, our navigation type is cheap, easy to use, and does not require additional expensive or complicated equipment. It reliably decreases malposition rate, allowing for implant placement in a proper position with sufficient bone-implant contact. Further research is needed to determine the relationship between CMAC position accuracy and long-term clinical and radiographic outcomes.

Funding

This research did not receive any specific grant from funding agencies in the public, commercial, or not-for-profit sectors.

Author contributions

All authors contributed to the study conception and design. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.

R. M. Tikhilov: writing – review & editing.

A. N. Kovalenko: formal analysis, writing – original draft.

A. A. Dzhavadov: investigation, resources.

S. S. Bilyk: investigation, resources.

I. I. Shubnyakov: writing – review & editing.

Ethical committee approval

This retrospective chart review study involving human participants was in accordance with the ethical standards of the institutional and national research committee and with the 1964 Helsinki Declaration and its later amendments or comparable ethical standards. A local ethics committee approved this study (№ 143, December 2, 2022).

The study was conducted at the Vreden National Medical Research Center of Traumatology and Orthopedics, Ministry of Health of Russian Federation, St. Petersburg, Russian Federation.

Consent to participate

Informed consent was obtained from all individual participants included in the study.

Consent to publish

Patients signed informed consent regarding publishing their data and photographs.

References

  1. , , , , , . Revision rates after total joint replacement: cumulative results from worldwide joint register datasets. J Bone Joint Surg Br. 2011 Mar;93(3):293-297.
    [Google Scholar]
  2. , , , , . Pelvic discontinuity in revision total hip arthroplasty. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1999 Dec;81(12):1692-1702.
    [Google Scholar]
  3. , , , , , . Acetabular revision using an anti-protrusion (ilio-ischial) cage and trabecular metal acetabular component for severe acetabular bone loss associated with pelvic discontinuity. J Bone Joint Surg Br. 2009 Jul;91(7):870-876.
    [Google Scholar]
  4. , , , , , . Cup-cage reconstruction for severe acetabular bone loss and pelvic discontinuity: mid-term Results of a Consecutive Series of 35 Cases. Bone Joint Lett J. 2018 Nov;100-B(11):1442-1448.
    [Google Scholar]
  5. , , , et al . Osseointegration of retrieved 3D-printed, off-the-shelf acetabular implants. Bone Joint Res. 2021 Jul;10(7):388-400.
    [Google Scholar]
  6. , , , . Extra-large uncemented hemispherical acetabular components for revision total hip arthroplasty. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2001 Sep;83(9):1352-1357.
    [Google Scholar]
  7. , , , , . Acetabular reconstruction with bone impaction grafting and a cemented cup: 20 years' experience. Clin Orthop Relat Res (393):202-215.
    [Google Scholar]
  8. , , , et al . Bilobed oblong porous coated acetabular components in revision total hip arthroplasty. Clin Orthop Relat Res (371):154-160.
    [Google Scholar]
  9. , , . Reconstruction of segmental defects during revision procedures of the acetabulum with the Burch-Schneider anti-protrusio cage. J Arthroplasty. 2001 Aug;16(5):568-574.
    [Google Scholar]
  10. , , , , , , . Acetabular distraction: an alternative for severe defects with chronic pelvic discontinuity? Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2012 Nov;470(11):3156-3163.
    [Google Scholar]
  11. , , , . Individuální titanová acetabulární komponenta vyrobená 3D tiskem: výhody a limity použití [Custom-Made 3D printed titanium acetabular component: advantages and limits of use] Acta Chir Orthop Traumatol Cech. 2021;88(1):69-74.
    [Google Scholar]
  12. , , , . Acetabular reconstruction with a custom-made triflange acetabular component through direct anterior approach - a case report. J Clin Orthop Trauma. 2020 Mar;11(Suppl 2):S211-S213.
    [Google Scholar]
  13. , , , , , , . Acetabular custom-made implants for severe acetabular bone defect in revision total hip arthroplasty: a systematic review of the literature. Arch Orthop Trauma Surg. 2020 Mar;140(3):415-424.
    [Google Scholar]
  14. , , , , . The accuracy of positioning of a custom-made implant within a large acetabular defect at revision arthroplasty of the hip. Bone Joint Lett J. 2015 Jun;97-B(6):780-785.
    [Google Scholar]
  15. , , , , , , . Customized implants for acetabular Paprosky III defects may be positioned with high accuracy in revision hip arthroplasty. Int Orthop. 2019 Oct;43(10):2235-2243.
    [Google Scholar]
  16. , , , , , , . Standard versus custom-made acetabular implants in revision total hip arthroplasty. J Arthroplasty. 2022 Jan;37(1):119-125.
    [Google Scholar]
  17. , , . Custom-made 3D-printed cup-cage implants for complex acetabular revisions: evaluation of pre-planned versus achieved positioning and 1-year migration data in 10 patients. Acta Orthop. 2021 Feb;92(1):23-28.
    [Google Scholar]
  18. , , , et al . Design of custom acetabular components: influence of the type of defects on the design. Russian Journal of Biomechanics. 2021;25(2):159-172.
    [Google Scholar]
Show Sections