Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with a single hamstring tendon graft and tape locking screw (TLS) fixation leads to good clinical outcome in two years of follow-up
Article History
-
Received: ,
Accepted: ,
Abstract
Abstract
There are many fixation methods for hamstring tendon autograft available for anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction. The intention of this study was to report clinical follow-up data of the Tape Locking Screw (TLS) reconstruction technique.
Does TLS method give good long term results in patient satisfaction and in clinical knee tests.
We selected 119 prospectively collected patients with a two-year follow-up who had an ACL reconstruction using TLS technique. A total of 114 cases were available for follow-up two years postoperatively. The evaluation methods were instrumented laxity measurements, clinical examination and knee scores.
The Lysholm and IKDC scores improved from preoperative 76 and 50 to 95 and 90, respectively. Tegner activity level before surgery was 3 and improved to 6 at 2 years postoperatively.
ACL reconstruction with TLS technique showed good objective outcome at the 2-year follow-up. We confirmed improvement in all evaluation method variables.
Case series; level of evidence, 4.
ISRCTN registry, study ID ISRCTN34011837. Registered retrospectively April 29, 2020.
Keywords
This article was originally published by Reed Elsevier India Pvt. Ltd. and was migrated to Scientific Scholar after the change of Publisher.
1 Introduction
There are many different operative methods for treating anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injuries. The optimal fixation method in ACL reconstruction has not yet been determined. Many new devices for reconstruction and graft fixation methods have been released for clinical use with varied clinical follow-up data.
In 2011, Collette and Cassard described a method using a single hamstring tendon constructed to form a short graft attached with two TLS braided polyethylene terephthalate strips and two TLS interference screws.1 The Tape Locking Screw (TLS) fixation method has shown good results in biomechanical studies and good reduction in postoperative laxity..2–4 The TLS technique is different from the other graft fixation methods in that the fixation material does not interfere with the graft; therefore, 360-degree incorporation into the bone socket is possible.
The aim of this study was to report clinical follow-up data of the TLS reconstruction technique. We also compared the 2-year results between primary ACL reconstructions (101 patients) and revision ACLRs (13 patients) in this study.
2 Patients and Methods
The study material was collected in a prospective manner, selection to this study was made retrospectively. We selected 119 patients with ACL injuries reconstructed with the TLS technique who attended the 2-year follow-up. There were 6 failures in need of a revision, and in 5 cases, the re-reconstructions were performed before the 2-year follow-up was due. Two of these patients had had a new injury, and in three cases, an early failure was noted. One patient attended the 2-year follow-up with a failed graft, the data was recorded, and the revision was performed after this. In two cases, both knees were operated on, one patient with the TLS technique in one knee and a BPTB graft in the other. One patient was treated with the TLS technique on both knees. These patients remained in the study because the clinical tests were performed preoperatively, and 2-year follow-up was carried out on the corresponding knee. Therefore, 114 cases were available for follow-up two years postoperatively. We also compared the 2-year results between primary ACL reconstructions (101 patients) and revision ACLRs (13 patients).
Of the 119 patients, 78 were male and 41 were female. All operations were performed by the same orthopaedic surgeon (AH) between November 2007 and July 2012. Knee scores (Lysholm, IKDC and Tegner), KT-2000 laxity measurements and clinical examination (pivot-shift and Lachman tests) were documented preoperatively and 2-years postoperatively.
Additional procedures included partial meniscectomy (medial 25, lateral 12), complete resection of 2 medial menisci, and refixation of menisci (medial 11, lateral 4) (Table 1). No cartilage procedures were performed.
| Partial meniscectomy | Medial25 | Lateral12 |
| Refixation of the meniscus | Medial11 | Lateral4 |
| Total resection of the meniscus | 2 |
2.1 Surgical technique
The TLS reconstruction technique used in our study was described in detail by Collette and Cassard.1
2.2 Preoperative and postoperative evaluations
The questionnaires for knee scores (Lysholm, IKDC and Tegner) were completed by the selected patients before the operation and at 2-year follow-up examinations. For the subjective evaluation, Lysholm knee scores (0–100) and IKDC (0–100) were used. The Tegner activity level was used to specify actual physical performance (1–10).
A clinical examination was conducted before the operation and at 2 years postoperatively. Instrumented anteroposterior knee laxity and side-to-side difference with manual maximum force were performed with KT-2000. The pivot-shift and Lachman tests were classified negative, slightly positive and clearly positive.
2.3 Rehabilitation
No knee braces were used. Postoperatively, immediate mobilization with partial weight bearing was permitted. Full weight was allowed 2 weeks postoperatively. At 3 weeks, patients started with bicycle exercises and other non-strenuous motion. After 6 weeks, with the guidance of a physiotherapist, proprioceptive exercises, active knee extension, deep-water running and weight training were added to the rehabilitation. Running and jumping were allowed at 3 months. At 6–12 months a progressive return to sports began. One year postoperatively, there were no restrictions on sports.
2.4 Statistical analysis
The data was processed with BMDP, Bio-Medical Data Package
Statistics (Statistical Solutions Ltd., Cork, Ireland).
3 Results
Pivot shift was positive (++) in three cases at the 2-year follow-up. One was a revision ACL reconstruction, and one patient presented with general laxity of the joints (Table 2).
| Lachman | |||
| – | + | ++ | |
| Preoperatively | 4 | 115 | |
| 2years postoperatively a | 85 | 23 | 5 |
| Pivot Shift | |||
| – | + | ++ | |
| Preoperatively | 3 | 116 | |
| 2years postoperatively a | 99 | 11 | 3 |
Lysholm and IKDC scores and Tegner activity level improved from preoperative values to the 2-year follow-up (Table 3).
| Preoperatively | 2-year follow-up | ||
| Lysholm | 76 (15–100) | 95 (44–100) | p < 0.001 |
| IKDC | 50 (16–92) | 90 (23–100) | p < 0.001 |
| Tegner | 3 (0–6) | 6 (1–10) | p < 0.001 |
The KT-2000 manual maximum force side-to-side laxity difference improved from preoperative mean 5.7 + −3.4 to 2-year follow-up 2.2 + −2.7.
We also compared the 2-year results between primary ACL reconstructions (101 patients) and revision ACLRs (13 patients). KT-2000 laxity measurements indicated no significant difference between the primary and revision ACLR repair (side-to-side difference 2.1 mm and 2.5 mm, respectively). The mean Lysholm score (p = 0.0002), IKDC (p = 0.016) and Tegner activity level (p = 0.0355) showed a significant difference in favour of the primary ACL reconstruction (Table 4).
| Mean | Primary ACL | Revision ACLR | |
| Lysholm | 92 | 79 | p = 0.0002 |
| IKDC score | 86 | 73 | p = 0.02 |
| Tegner | 6.1 | 4.9 | p = 0.04 |
| Manual Max | 2.1 | 2.5 | p = 0.7 |
The 2-year follow-up results of the pivot shift and Lachman tests between these groups show no significant differences (Table 5).
| Primary ACL | Revision ACLRa | ||
| Pivot shift - | 88 | 8 | |
| + | 9 | 2 | |
| ++ | 4 | 1 | Chi square 0.2769 |
| Lachman - | 79 | 6 | |
| + | 18 | 4 | |
| ++ | 4 | 1 | Chi square 0.2433 |
4 Discussion
The paramount finding of this retrospective study was that the TLS technique with a single tendon graft seemed to give good results in terms of functional stability and knee laxity.
Kruppa et al.5 conducted a biomechanical study fixing fourfold-strand flexor tendon grafts in porcine tibiae using bioabsorbable interference screws. They pretensioned the grafts at 80 N over 10 min and inserted the screws with the preload still applied. Graft force was documented for 24 h. They found that the intra-articular graft force decreased continuously during the recorded time when tibial interference screw fixation was used. This might have occurred because of an elongation of the graft, a failure at the bone or graft and screw slippage effect.
In this study, according to the TLS technique, graft preloading was done with 500 N force for 2 min. This may prevent the elongation of the graft and therefore enhance the stability of the knee after reconstruction surgery.
Plaweski and Lantemier6 compared two ACL reconstruction techniques in patients. In the first group, the graft comprised a ST4 graft (semitendinosus graft prepared in four strands); in the second group, the graft was a STG graft. Graft fixation on the femoral side was achieved with cortical suspension in both groups. As for the tibial side, the ST4 graft was attached according to the TLS technique, and in the STG group, an interference screw was employed. The functional scores were compatible in both groups at the 3-year follow-up; however, the laxity test measured with the KT-1000 arthrometry showed significantly better stability in favour of the ST4 graft.
In a prospective single-centre, single-surgeon study, Orfeuvre et al.3 published the results of 61 ACL reconstruction patients operated on using the TLS technique. Their primary objective was to define postoperative side-to-side laxity after a minimum follow-up of one year. They found, similar to what our study showed, that the TLS technique leads to a very good decrease in postoperative laxity.
Manchado-Herrera et al.7 published a retrospective observational study of 26 patients who had an ACL reconstruction surgery with the TLS technique. Median Lysholm (97.5) and IKDC (95.4) scores showed nearly normal values with no deterioration up to the 5-year follow-up. Our 2-year follow-up median Lysholm (95) and IKDC (90) scores compare well with their results.
Ayzenberg et al.8 studied the biomechanical strength of the TLS fixation system by implanting it into 22 frozen human distal femora using titanium or polyetheretherketone (PEEK) screws. The graft in this technique is secured to two polyethylene terephthalate tapes. To isolate the device to test it biomechanically, they implanted the construct without any graft. They found no statistical difference between the PEEK or titanium screw fixation and the technique provided eminent pull-out strengths compared to other ACL fixation methods for soft tissue. The primary reason for failure was tape slippage at the screw–bone interface. In our study, titanium screws were used in all cases.
Pacull et al.9 also conducted a biomechanical study using porcine and human models. They compared the TLS, ACLip Femoral and ToggleLoc Ziploop (TLZ) implants. The goal of the study was to determine the overall elongation of an ACL reconstruction when using a short hamstring graft. The evaluation methods were cycling (1000 cycles between 50 and 250 N, 1 Hz), creep test (50 N for 30 s) and load to failure (50 mm/min). Their results of the low performance of the femoral TLS fixations at load to failure at 557 ± 163 N were comparable to those reported by Ayzenberg et al.8 (616 ± 177 N). After cycling the TLS and ACLip implants had the smallest elongations. In our study, there were 6 failures in need of revision. The reasons for the failures were not recorded.
The pull-out strength of various graft fixation devices is perhaps the most important prerequisite for successful ACL reconstruction. This is especially important when soft tissue grafts are used. In an extensive study, Kousa et al.10,11 tested the pull-out strength of 6 different fixation devices on both the tibial and femoral sides. Bone mulch fixation was found to be the strongest, with endobutton fixation as the second strongest. The calculated pull-out strength of the TLS fixation yielded similar values as when other devices were used.4
Another challenge when using soft tissue grafts is tunnel enlargement due to graft movement within the tunnels. However, when short grafts and short bony sockets are used, this problem seems to be avoided. Furthermore, the bony tunnels, excluding the bone sockets, are only 4.5 mm in width.
Collette and Cassard1 reported a failure rate of 4.4% among 134 patients. Three patients presented with an infection postoperatively. Colin et al.12 reported two cases of aseptic arthritis amongst 307 patients. They speculated that the aseptic arthritis was caused by polyethylene terephthalate (PET) tape particles from the femoral tunnel invading the joint cavity and causing aseptic arthritis. This theory was later questioned by Cassard et al.,13 who claimed that they had never seen a “foreign body” reaction associated with the use of intraosseal PET strips. However, they correctly emphasized the importance of cutting the PET strip ends short at the femoral bony tunnel.
We recorded 6 failures (5%), two of which had had a new trauma. This is in accordance with other similar studies, where the incidence of graft failure after ACL reconstruction is reported to be 3–14%.14,15 Collette and Cassard1 reported a failure rate of 4.4% using the TLS technique, but their 134 patients were operated on at three different centres, and the follow-up time was between 6 and 36 months. Using the same TLS technique, Orfeuvre et al.3 reported a re-rupture rate of 3.2%. We collected the Tegner score in this study, but no detailed return-to-sports analysis was conducted. In a modern study analysing the results after ACL reconstruction, this perhaps should be included since in most similar studies, the population mainly comprises young, active people, and in most of the cases, the primary incident has been a sports injury.
Our study has some limitations. Patients to this study were recruited prospectively, but the patient selection was based on the operation technique and was therefore done retrospectively. Furthermore, one surgeon (AH) performed all the reconstructions and was also taking part in the examination of patients at follow-up.
5 Conclusion
ACL reconstruction with the TLS technique showed good clinical results at the 2-year follow-up. We confirmed improvement in all evaluation method variables.
When comparing 2-year results between primary ACL reconstructions and revision ACLRs, the results showed a significant difference in Tegner activity level, Lysholm and IKDC scores in favour of the primary ACL reconstruction.
Ethical statement
Ethical approval was obtained from The Hospital District of Helsinki and Uusimaa Operative Ethics Committee.
Funding
This work was supported by Orton research grants from the Ministry of Social Affairs and Health, Finland. (A2500464).
The financing body played no role in designing the study, collecting, analysing and interpreting data or in writing the manuscript.
CRediT authorship contribution statement
Leena Metso: processed the data and wrote this article. Ville Bister: was involved in co-ordinating the study, as well as in the writing of this article, All authors have read and approved the final manuscript. Arsi Harilainen: performed the surgeries and with. Jerker Sandelin: they were the originators of this study, They also participated in the writing process.
Patient Consent
Informed consent was obtained from all individual participants included in the study.
References
- The Tape Locking Screw technique (TLS): a new ACL reconstruction method using a short hamstring graft. Orthop Traumatol Surg Res. 2011;97(5):555-559.
- [Google Scholar]
- A biomechanical analysis of tibial fixation methods in hamstring-graft anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. Iowa Orthop J. 2019;39(1):141-147.
- [Google Scholar]
- Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with the Tape Locking Screw (TLS) and a short hamstring graft: clinical evaluation of 61 cases with a minimum 12 months' follow-up. Orthop Traumatol Surg Res. 2018;104(5):701-705.
- [Google Scholar]
- A comparison of four tibial-fixation systems in hamstring-graft anterior ligament reconstruction. Eur J Orthop Surg Traumatol. 2015;25(2):339-347.
- [Google Scholar]
- Significant loss of ACL graft force with tibial-sided soft tissue interference screw fixation over 24 hours: a biomechanical study. Orthop J Sports Med. 2020;4(5):8.
- [Google Scholar]
- Is quadruple semitendinosus tendon strands autograft a better choice than hamstring autograft for anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction? A comparative study with a mean follow-up of 3 years. Eur J Orthop Surg Traumatol. 2020;30(8):1473-1479.
- [Google Scholar]
- Anterior tibial translation and patient-reported outcomes after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with a tape locking screw: a 5-year follow-up study. Orthop Traumatol Surg Res. 2021;107(2)
- [Google Scholar]
- Pullout strength of a novel hybrid fixation technique (Tape Locking Screw) in soft-tissue ACL reconstruction. A biomechanical study in human and porcine bone. Orthop Traumatol Surg Res. 2017;103(4):591-595.
- [Google Scholar]
- Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with short hamstring grafts: the choice of femoral xation device matters in controlling overall lengthening. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc. 2022;30:2215-2226.
- [Google Scholar]
- The fixation strength of six hamstring tendon graft fixation devices in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. Part I: femoral site. Am J Sports Med. 2003;31(2):174-181.
- [Google Scholar]
- The fixation strength of six hamstring tendon graft fixation devices in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. Part II: tibial site. Am J Sports Med. 2003;31(2):182-188.
- [Google Scholar]
- Aseptic arthritis after ACL reconstruction by Tape Locking Screw (TLS): report of two cases. Orthop Traumatol Surg Res. 2012;98(3):363-365.
- [Google Scholar]
- Comments on: “Aseptic arthritis after ACL reconstruction by Tape Locking Screw (TLS): report of two cases”. Orthop Traumatol Surg Res 2012. 2012;98(3):363-365.
- [Google Scholar]
- The first results from the Danish ACL reconstruction registry: epidemiologic and 2 year follow-up results from 5,818 knee ligament reconstructions. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc. 2009;17(2):117-124.
- [Google Scholar]
- Risk of secondary injury in younger athletes after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction: a systematic review and Meta-analysis. Am J Sports Med. 2016;44(7):1861-1876.
- [Google Scholar]

